That was the first hit miller delivered all season. What a waste he is
Player Discussion Filip Chytil: Part III
- Thread starter Leonardo87
- Start date
eco's bones
Registered User
When Lafontaine and Keane collided it was a bit nastier looking than last night.
Filip did come back to finish out the 2nd period and the shift or two he took he looked okay. He was involved behind the net and along the boards.
Hopefully it's not bad but I think there's a decent chance he goes on IR or LTIR. I also don't think the Rangers are going out west for 4 games with just 12 forwards so I'd expect them to call someone up. It won't be Othmann who hasn't been playing. Most likely to get recalled--Rempe, Berard, Groulx or Leschyshyn. Maybe some chance for Sykora but I think it will be one of the first four. In any case I think Brodzinski is the most likely to fill in at 3C for now.
On the hit itself. It was an accident. Like others here I'm not happy with how Miller's been playing but there's no way he's trying to take out his own player and he probably feels pretty bad about it. Basically the Rangers want their D to pinch down to keep plays alive in the offensive zone and there was little enough of a forecheck from our team the first half of the game.
Filip did come back to finish out the 2nd period and the shift or two he took he looked okay. He was involved behind the net and along the boards.
Hopefully it's not bad but I think there's a decent chance he goes on IR or LTIR. I also don't think the Rangers are going out west for 4 games with just 12 forwards so I'd expect them to call someone up. It won't be Othmann who hasn't been playing. Most likely to get recalled--Rempe, Berard, Groulx or Leschyshyn. Maybe some chance for Sykora but I think it will be one of the first four. In any case I think Brodzinski is the most likely to fill in at 3C for now.
On the hit itself. It was an accident. Like others here I'm not happy with how Miller's been playing but there's no way he's trying to take out his own player and he probably feels pretty bad about it. Basically the Rangers want their D to pinch down to keep plays alive in the offensive zone and there was little enough of a forecheck from our team the first half of the game.
Shesterkybomb
Registered User
- Dec 30, 2016
- 16,573
- 17,808
Just watched the clip.
2 things
1. Man the kid really doesn't keep his head up, like you can't see that redwood tree ahead of you?
2. If that is all it takes to put him out he shouldn't be in the nhl anymore. His health is on the line. Unfortunately he was our best center this year but realistically if that's all it takes he'll never play for us in playoffs anyway. We probably should have used the Smith assets on someone that could play center or wing.
2 things
1. Man the kid really doesn't keep his head up, like you can't see that redwood tree ahead of you?
2. If that is all it takes to put him out he shouldn't be in the nhl anymore. His health is on the line. Unfortunately he was our best center this year but realistically if that's all it takes he'll never play for us in playoffs anyway. We probably should have used the Smith assets on someone that could play center or wing.
I agree, it's unfortunate but his brain gets rattled too easily. He was finally coming into his own too.
Priorae
Registered User
I absolutely agree. The hope here is that its an over abundance of caution, but I think reality is that this kid is one hard hit away from major life problems. Similar to Tua with the Dolphins. The talent is so attractive, but there's no reliability and the downside risk is just unacceptable.
HockeyBasedNYC
Feeling it
I was expecting them to keep him out of the game after that hit, regardless of if he said he was good to go or not.
I think its a bad sign that he came back but then left after a shift
I think its a bad sign that he came back but then left after a shift
will1066
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2008
- 48,067
- 67,111
He does not have awareness, which is too bad. He's like a racehorse with blinders, and he's usually flying around in a crouched way instead of upright.
The Crypto Guy
Registered User
- Jun 26, 2017
- 28,256
- 36,782
Same can be said for Miller, who should have had a clearer view of Chytil coming up. Chytil was looking toward the boards at the puck, Miller was coming down looking at everything.
TopShelfSnipes
Registered User
Othmann is hurt.
As for the collision, yes, Lafontaine/Keane was worse, and the impact wasn't as severe, but Fil's head still decelerated rapidly. Remember that concussions are about the brain being exposed to acceleration/deceleration forces inside the head, not about the impact of the head on whatever contact surface.
And yeah, I don't get the Miller hate. He's been playing kinda shitty so far but no one's trying to take out their own teammate.
If Chytil was wearing a Shark sweater, Miller would have missed him because he would have been sprawled out on his belly 12 feet away.
SeanAveryTheGreatOne
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2021
- 742
- 1,476
haohmaru
boomshakalaka
Peltz
Registered User
- Oct 4, 2019
- 3,746
- 5,250
Unfortunately, a cage probably wouldn't have made a difference. Concussions don't require that the head actually touch something. Any impact causing the head to move in a jarring fashion (even within a cage) could be enough to cause the same damage. That's why football players, who wear a cage, still get CTE and have tremendous issues unfortunately.
At this point, it's about the movement of his brain within his skull, not external impact to the skull itself.
I'm upset as a fan of the team because he's been our best center and if healthy could have been what got us further than last year in the playoffs. The team was at its deepest with his play this year.
But as a fan of the player, I hope he retires if this is the type of contact that will concuss him. I will still remember him fondly and his quality of life is far more important than any impact he will have on the franchise even if they did win a cup. At the end of the day, it's a game and not worth sacrificing any player's quality of life.
And if you're criticizing Miller for his play as of late, that's fine. But this aint the thing to get mad at him for. Incidental collisions happen in this sport and it was unintentional. Lay off the guy for this.
will1066
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2008
- 48,067
- 67,111
Kinda stating the obvious here... everyone pretty much knew going in this year, you just can't trust this poor kid to stay healthy. I hate to say it, because I really think the kid has high end talent. But I think you have to start planning for a future without Chytil. And ideally I think you'd like to go toward youth in this case.
Mika and Trocheck are both 31. Zibanejad's game has obviously fallen off a cliff. I posted a bit ago about Mika's 5v5 play last year. His 5v5 production dropped to that of a 3rd liner/role player. It's crazy. His numbers are inflated from being a passenger on a top powerplay unit. At this point who knows if he can turn it around or not. Hopefully this isn't the beginning of the end for him. This team will struggle big time if he can't get it together.
Ideal scenario you go out and identify a young talented center with upside to fill in that 3C spot. Hopefully it's a player that can develop enough to supplant one of the 2 veterans when the time comes. Either way we need to get some actual high end center prospects in the system. We have almost nothing. Laba is really the only one I have any hope for to be more than just a plug
Mika and Trocheck are both 31. Zibanejad's game has obviously fallen off a cliff. I posted a bit ago about Mika's 5v5 play last year. His 5v5 production dropped to that of a 3rd liner/role player. It's crazy. His numbers are inflated from being a passenger on a top powerplay unit. At this point who knows if he can turn it around or not. Hopefully this isn't the beginning of the end for him. This team will struggle big time if he can't get it together.
Ideal scenario you go out and identify a young talented center with upside to fill in that 3C spot. Hopefully it's a player that can develop enough to supplant one of the 2 veterans when the time comes. Either way we need to get some actual high end center prospects in the system. We have almost nothing. Laba is really the only one I have any hope for to be more than just a plug
Whoot Whoot
Biased Rangers Fan
KirkAlbuquerque
#WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
will1066
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2008
- 48,067
- 67,111
eco's bones
Registered User
Rangers/Pack have pretty much used Edstrom exclusively on the wing so far. For now I would expect Brodzinski to slot in for Filip. Groulx might be another option. There is some offense to his game though whether he has the ability to fill a 3C role at the NHL level would be something of a question. He is off to a pretty decent start with the Pack this year and he's got decent size.
Then why did he come back in? Someone should be fired for that if he is concussed again.
Could be that he passed the tests.
Came back. Didn’t feel 100% and the team said “don’t push it”
Jaromir Jagr
Registered User
I have no medical experience at all but always understood concussions to be a bit of an enigma. How good is a concussion test right after something happens? Could adrenaline help a player immediately pass (or like they're lying to themselves in a dazed state and pass)?
Or is it really unlikely that they'd be able to fake their way out of it (either by lying or due to adrenaline)?
Obviously not assuming it's impossible that he could pass and then later they realize it's a concussion, but wondering how thorough these are and whether there is some hope that maybe it was largely precaution after passing the concussion test but feeling somehwat dazed.
The concussion tests rely heavily on tracking eye movement and coordination.
It’s easy to pass, especially if a player doesn’t want to report it.
- Jul 28, 2011
- 16,129
- 10,842
I think he was visibly upset that they pulled him off. Concussion protocol, perhaps?
Typically these test are strictly for "Hey, what condition are you currently in. Do we see signs of a visible concussion. Are you functional enough to make choices." The testing here doesn't 100% determine if a concussion took place and more used for players not just going back on the rink while dizzy or suffering from any real use of judgement. Last thing you want is a player calling the shots and looking like his eyes are in the back of his head, which is really the main part of the testing here.
Last edited:
