Elias Pettersson vs Tim Stützle

[NyQuil]

I haven't voted yet, Debate and entertain me for my vote!

I’m just waiting for you to insert a much better New Jersey Devil into the discussion.

 

[Xirik]

I’m just waiting for you to insert a much better New Jersey Devil into the discussion.

 

[NyQuil]

View attachment 925474

At this point of the discussion, you would have introduced a casserole dish with a Devils logo on it.

 

[Xirik]

At this point of the discussion, you would have introduced a casserole dish with a Devils logo on it.

which discussion are we talking about? One you are imagining?

 

[Coffee]

NyQuil and Xirik are my two of my favourite posters, bit shocked to see a little hiccup here.

But then again I’ve had my fair share of hiccups with both

 

[Nico Hischier]

Pettersson got absolutely smothered by Hischier last night

It wasn’t too long ago on these boards where people thought NJD was foolish for drafting Nico over Pettersson or that Pettersson would be the best forward from the 2017 draft class.

I haven’t been watching Vancouver games this year but it sounds like Pettersson has been playing bad hockey ever since he got his contract extension.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Both are not as good as Suzuki, and that's what truly matters in the end

 

[Phrasing]

It wasn’t too long ago on these boards where people thought NJD was foolish for drafting Nico over Pettersson or that Pettersson would be the best forward from the 2017 draft class.

I’m not sure that has changed yet.

 

[NyQuil]

I really should have taken a screenshot back when it was 70/30.

 

[Coffee]

It wasn’t too long ago on these boards where people thought NJD was foolish for drafting Nico over Pettersson or that Pettersson would be the best forward from the 2017 draft class.

I haven’t been watching Vancouver games this year but it sounds like Pettersson has been playing bad hockey ever since he got his contract extension.

We’ll see what ends up happening

I really should have taken a screenshot back when it was 70/30.

You really think people changed votes? But like, where’s the integrity ? I dont buy it

 

[Golden_Jet]

We’ll see what ends up happening


You really think people changed votes? But like, where’s the integrity ? I dont buy it

I don’t think poster is saying anyone changed votes, think assumption is most of new votes are going to Stutzle.

 

[Coffee]

I don’t think poster is saying anyone changed votes, think assumption is most of new votes are going to Stutzle.

You’re probably wrong, I say kindly and gently

This poll was much more one-sided when it was made.

Change vote is a hell of a drug.

 

[Golden_Jet]

You’re probably wrong, I say kindly and gently

I lol kindly and gently ,
ok then, why is the vote much closer now.
So you don’t think votes were changed
And you don’t think new votes are going to Stutzle.

Maybe you can explain why then, is it magic.

 

[Coffee]

I lol kindly and gently ,
ok then, why is the vote much closer now.
So you don’t think votes were changed
And you don’t think new votes are going to Stutzle.

Maybe you can explain why then, it’s magic.

We have a misunderstanding I believe

I agree the new votes are going to Stutzle, I was challenging NyQuil on his thought (kindly and gently), that people are changing votes


You said the poster (I think you were referring to Nyqs) wasn’t referring to people changing votes, so I just posted his quote of him saying exactly that

 

[Samsquanch]

Would be interesting to see this poll if it was ran from scratch today. It would be very hard not to take Stutzle at this point, and EP has had more than enough time to work his way out of a "slump" and change the narrative on him this season.

Something doesnt smell right with EP, imo. Not only does he play behind another very elite centerman (and apparently now has some friction with him off the ice) but his motivation and compete level seems to come and go to often for my liking. Especially if you consider his massive new contract.

Every part of Stutzles game looks like its still getting better. hes playing the most minutes of any forward and in all situations, and his defensive game has grown by leaps and bounds. And the list of players that are more valuable than Stutzle on his current deal is growing smaller every day.