I agree.
No offense, Duguay, but I wouldn't say Ottawa is better off today for having a revolving door of coaches and management over the last 6 years. They've won 2 playoff rounds in 6 years, which means they either DNQ'd or lost in the first round 4 times. They might make the playoffs this year but I don't think of them as a team on the rise like TML or BUF and I don't think of them as a former top-tier team going through a rebuild like BOS.
Fwiw, I'm not all-in on the Sweeney love affair either. I didn't like his early moves, and I think a lot of the things he's getting credit for now were at least partly unintentional. He seems to have a real hard time making a trade that can help in the here and now. I think his motives are misunderstood by even his biggest supporters and I think he and Cam are **** poor communicators of their vision and plan for this team.
BUT, there's also enough good there that I think it's worth waiting to see where this leads. I give him a lot of credit for not throwing the coach under the bus last season when it would have completely distracted and deflected the blame from him and the job he's done. I like that he hasn't gone crazy in free agency, drawing the line and sticking to it on certain players. I like that he let Eriksson go, a player who's already worn out his welcome in VAN. I like that he has a plan to manage the cap. And I like that he places a premium on drafting and developing. Honestly, if you can do that last thing right the rest is window dressing.
I would agree that he has to make the playoffs to keep his job. I would also agree that they need one more piece to get over the hump and secure a playoff spot. But I'm not sure Sweeney is capable of that kind of deal, and I'm not sure I'm convinced that new player has to be a game changer. It would be nice, but they went from the 2nd worst offense in the league when Vatrano was out to 9th in the league in just the 12 games they've had Vatrano back. Not all of that is Frankie V, Bergeron has finally started to come around as well, and I think if they added one more piece to get that 3rd line going they'd finally have the kind of team they want. A team that's 4 lines deep, coming at you with a combination of speed through the neutral zone, heavy offensive zone play, and activated offensive defensemen on every pair.
Can he get that final piece? I think he can, he added Liles/Stempniak last year and while I think most want to see a big name/major addition come in, I expect it's going to be someone like Hanzal or Dan Boyle to center the 3rd line who's capable of 20 goals or 40 points. That seems more in his wheel house and he'll still be able to protect the futures he wants to protect.
No offense taken PM, just pointing out the nature of hockey in relation to pro-activity. Are the Sens better for it? Well, if they are it is in an Erik Karlsson kind of better.
Not unlike the Bourque days in Boston.
And yes, both through the Draft.
If the Sens had their #1 Goalie in, I would pick them ahead of Boston unfortunately. I see them as a slightly better team, and their future with Colin White, Curtis Lazar, Cody Ceci and Chabot looks pretty good to me. So present day and moving forward, we'll have to battle them one way or another.
I guess point being, we need an Erik Karlsson. I get to watch the guy night after night, and mark my words, he is outstanding. He's a game changer. I guess we wait for the kid (Charlie Boy) and hope he can push Boston's program into a Top 10 program.
After getting over the fact I thought he looked lazy, I sure got to like him well enough in the WJC and I do concur with the Doughty comparison.
Otherwise sounds like we are like-minded in regards to the plans we'd like to see actualize.
I still think DS should make a bold stroke. One of the teams that is falling off may unload a future star for some futures to streamline a budget. I think we can offer up some prospects (uncertainty) for a young roster player.
If we don't, other teams will. Not saying there isn't a limit, but we have many players here also who -- one way or another-- shouldn't be a part of the long term plan.
Some of them older, some of them not fitting in.
This bold stroke could also save Sweeney's job. And trust me, I am not looking for a bold Mike O'Connell desperation belly flop either, haha