But he is not a 30 pt player, at least he has never been, his best season was 26 pts in his first yr & only one other yr had 21 pts, the rest of the time he was under 20 pts. I guess it depends on what you want on that 3rd line, do you want an energy player or do you want more secondary scoring when the top two lines have bad nights or go into droughts? Do you want a 40 pt player on the 3rd line that can be moved up when injuries occur on the top two lines or do you move up an energy player?
Kubalik has had two 40 pt plus seasons & two 30 plus pt seasons in the last 4 yrs which makes him the better pt producer, at least on paper. Kubalik isn't slow either, he is pretty fast too, but he doesn't play the energy game that Joseph does & they still have a number of guys who are fast & with the addition of Norris & Pinto eventually they are fast as well & both are good defensively & can play on the PK or PP. Arguable yes, but they could have much more versatility on the roster with Kubalik than Joseph in this regard. It's a tough decision.
I do agree Joseph is a prototypical top 9 tweener. If we weren't missing Pinto & Greig needed more time in Belleville I would agree to keep him because he is off to such a good start, but with a full lineup up does his ice time get reduced, does his chances get reduced therefore affecting his productivity? It will be interesting to see how this plays out & what there solution is that supposedly is already in place once Pinto's camp agrees to a contract.