Do all 3 Hughes brothers go 1st overall in their respective re-drafts?

[ninetyeight]

Quinn has the best competition, but he's also the best of the three. I think with Luke it's between him and Guenther. But it's very early and things can change quickly. But some of these takes are comical, Moser????? He's like THREE years older than Luke.

Edvinsson, Power, maybe? It's hard to say when their teams are doing bad, but Power's defensive metrics don't impress. Johnston? Maybe last year, but unless he picks it back up this year he shouldn't be in the conversation. Right now he's pacing for similar production that Luke had at his rookie year as a defenceman.

 

[bobholly39]

Jack and Quinn unquestionably #1. Quinn may have some strong competition in his year, but doesn't mean he doesn't still stand out as the clear #1 in the group.

Luke? No idea. As others have said, it's too early to tell. Maybe?

 

[sensfan4lifee]

Edvinsson is 7 months older than Luke lmao. He's also not a rookie.

Giving Edvinsson credit for being unable to crack an NHL roster until like a year and a half older is wild.

"better defensively".
Except luke gives up significantly less expected goals than any of the other dmen (and creates significantly more offensively
View attachment 947831


Disagree.

Maybe early in the year when he was playing it safe, but he's been better offensively for the last month +.

Detroit takes there time with prospects thats why Edvinson took this long, also yes Edvinson will be a better player than Luke Hughes whom I actually like, but I feel like Edvinson will be a big two way beast on D.