What is he suposed to do? Tlusty is the best forwar on the market, and the only assets we have that are remotely worth anything in a trade are draft picks, Schneider, Larsson, Severson, and Greene. I guess Cammalleri and Henrique too, but obviously we wouldn't trade them.
Merrill nor Gelinas are going to bring in a star forward. They're just not. We have nothing to trade...
I'm not bashing Shero yet, but he's definitely let some opportunities slide.
1. He could have signed a couple of vets. The Devils right wing depth is atrocious. Someone like Santorelli would have helped.
2. He could have been more aggressive at the draft. The fact that the Devils didn't trade into the first round is a red flag. In the end, it means that the Devils preferred their quantity of picks and prospects vs. the chance at higher end talent. Barzal, Konecny - there are a number of guys that, if the Devils had been more aggressive, could have upgraded the forward talent pool.
3. He could have been more aggressive in off-season trades. It's unclear how the Hurricanes outbid the Devils on the Versteeg salary dump. The Canes get Versteeg plus upgraded from a 5th round pick to a 3rd. The Devils may not have been able to match the offer for Reilly Smith (though, the Bruins should be in the market for a d-man), but there's another forward who could have upgraded the talent pool.
None of these issues are necessarily the wrong decision. It all depends on what Shero does going forward. Maybe Blackwood and Speers pan out. Maybe Shero is able to pick up a salary dump who's not even on the radar.
But, the idea that there was nothing for Shero to do so far is incorrect, I think. With some imagination and vision, there was plenty Shero could have done.
As someone who would prefer to see a competitive team this year, I think Shero has been too passive so far. But, Shero certainly deserves the chance to let his decisions play out for a couple of years before he's held accountable.