Ty Smith netted us Marino
Hall netted us Mercer, Bahl, and Siegenthaler
You’re being disingenuous.
And what did the Subban trade prevent us from doing? We gave up no prime assets for a guy who was 12 months removed from a Norris nomination. There was no long term commitment either. Team was going to go for it after winning another lottery and with Hall entering UFA. Gusev and Subban didn’t work out but almost everyone was lauding those moves.
Ok, now you did it.
I don’t think it makes sense to cast this as Team Lou vs Team Shero. That’s not how I see the team’s history.
But this weird over the top defense of Shero is over the top.
If a Flyers or Rangers GM turned a pile of good assets (2019 2nd #34, 2020 2nd #37, 2021 2nd #36, 2022 3rd #68) into nothingess before the last pick was even used, they would get roasted on this board.
When you suck your 2nds are more valuable, we sucked very hard, so our three 2nds were valuable.
Bad teams shouldn’t pretend they aren’t bad and trade multiple 2nds away just because they’re desperate and have nothing else to trade.
This is why we have a thinner prospect pool than Buffalo or Detroit despite sucking forever just like them (or longer in the case of Detroit).
And we would have been in big trouble if “the Summer of Shero” somehow managed to be successful and we didn’t sell in 2019-20. The only reason we’re successful now is the Summer of Shero was an immediate complete bust.
And, no, not everyone was sold on that approach at the time. It all worked out for the best but that “best” part required Shero to 1) take a huge F for Fail in 2019-20 2) get fired for it. It wouldn’t have worked out without a reset with Fitz.