Prospect Info: David Reinbacher

[Nevins]

 

[FF de Mars]

That's Hughes' being transparent! Doesn't mean he can forecast the future. It looks like he's managing his own expectations.

 

[Grate n Colorful Oz]

.Not if you take 12 in 30 and compare it with Ovy's 23 in 53? Moreover Ovy must have weighted at least 60 pounds more and was 6 inches taller and skated faster. Moreover Ovy played for a real team wheras Michkov played for Sochi. Michkov has 0 points in 3 games with SKA, how many points would have he scored had he played on a real team too?

i think you forgot the part where Ovy also had points against weak teams. Need to account for those too. Also, that makes it 12 in 28, not 12 in 30. If you remove the points, remove the games. 12 in 28 is 0.428 ppg and 23 in 53 is 43.3 ppg. So exactly like I said, remove those 8 points and Michkov is still really close to Ovy. Now remove whatever point Ovy got against the weakest team and Michkov is on top for most ppg, just like I said.

All this bs about real team is ridiculous. He still faced KHL opposition every night.

 

[Habs]

That's Hughes' being transparent! Doesn't mean he can forecast the future. It looks like he's managing his own expectations.

That's just pathetic to burn a #5 pick on a 2nd pairing dman who may or may not run the PP, what a moron we have in charge. I thought 'hey maybe Kent knows something about the kid and he's special' Nope. What a butthead.

 

[Xirik]

people complain about the Habs rushing talent to the NHL but then go crazy if the top pick isn't in the NHL the next season.

Though I'm guessing this time a lot of people want to rush him because they are so bitter that they want Reinbacher to fail just to go "See! SEE!!".

 

[DAChampion]

Though I'm guessing this time a lot of people want to rush him because they are so bitter that they want Reinbacher to fail just to go "See! SEE!!".

Really, like who?

 

[Rapala]

The difference is Price was categorized potentiel franchise player for the start.

Michkov had that same potential franchise player potential

Reinbacher? Not so much. Hughes even said he had potential of a 2D. Not even top D.

Completely different.

2D is top pairing teams often refer to 1D as left and 2D as right. Jeff Petry wasn't a 2D he was a 3D or a 4D depending on how you look at it.

 

[Gravity]

That's Hughes' being transparent! Doesn't mean he can forecast the future. It looks like he's managing his own expectations.

You don't draft a #2D at 5th OV over Michkov......

 

[dackelljuneaubulis02]

I would have taken a chance at Michkov even if we were too see him play in 3 years. As for who they selected, seems like an interesting pick and long-term project like Slaf. He might become another Komisarek or the next Weber.

I don’t think he’s long term at all. I think he’ll be with the Habs by 24-25

 

[Jaynki]

Delete

 

[River Meadow]

Simon "The Snake" Boisvert loves Redenbacher and that's good enough for me.

 

[Rapala]

You don't draft a #2D at 5th OV over Michkov......

The entire scouting staff had him pegged as their Guy. What does that tell you?
Michkov was never even considered get over it.
They did their due diligence by meeting the kid but they were never going to pick him.

 

[Kobe Armstrong]

2023 NHL Entry Draft

https://www.sportsnet.ca/nhl/article/sportsnets-2023-nhl-draft-prospect-rankings-february-edition/ https://www.sportsnet.ca/nhl/article/scouts-analysis-top-40-prospects-in-2023-and-how-to-build-a-draft-list/

forums.hfboards.com

2023 NHL Entry Draft

Whats the thing about Musty ? Numbers are good , size is great He doesnt seem too well liked here He is wildly inconsistent as an offensive play-driver at the Junior level. Some games Musty looks absolutely elite offensively, and grossly outmatches defenders with smarts, quick plays and pure...

forums.hfboards.com

Called it clear as day on February 20th

 

[Xirik]

Someone humor me and tell me what a 1D is.

 

[Jaynki]

You don't draft a #2D at 5th OV over Michkov......

Then imagine drafting a defenseman who had 10 points in 29 games in a f***ing junior leagues. And who also happen to be a Russian, in front of Michkov, at 6OV.

That should tell you everything you need to know about picking top pairing RD at 5OV over Michkov

 

[Demigod Gloves]

watch some game tape

Haven't seen anything close to Pronger, could you please share some of the videos you're seeing.

 

[Rapala]

people complain about the Habs rushing talent to the NHL but then go crazy if the top pick isn't in the NHL the next season.

Though I'm guessing this time a lot of people want to rush him because they are so bitter that they want Reinbacher to fail just to go "See! SEE!!".

I don't know about that. Most fans saw top 3 as NHL ready maybe top 4. This assuming Michkov would still be under contract.
Everyone else in the top 10 a year out at the most.

Someone humor me and tell me what a 1D is.

Hall Gill

 

[Demigod Gloves]

Someone humor me and tell me what a 1D is.

It's definitely not David...as per our GM

 

[Retired]

You don't draft a #2D at 5th OV over Michkov......

History says you do that 100% of the time so….

 

[Scriptor]

That's just pathetic to burn a #5 pick on a 2nd pairing dman who may or may not run the PP, what a moron we have in charge. I thought 'hey maybe Kent knows something about the kid and he's special' Nope. What a butthead.

A D2 is not a 2nd pairing D, from what I gather, but, rather, a #2 D, or a first pairing D that rounds out the first pairing with a more offensive #1D on the same pairing:

Hutson - Reinbacher, for example.

 

[Habs]

A D2 is not a 2nd pairing D, from what I gather, but, rather, a #2 D, or a first pairing D that rounds out the first pairing with a more offensive #1D on the same pairing:

Hutson - Reinbacher, for example.

a few scouts said he's a second pairing guy, that's my new expectations after listening to old Kento as well.

 

[Vachon23]

I don't dislike Reinbacher but I was one of the rare weirdos who said we should have drafted a D last year instead of Slaf or Wright, looking at last year's class and this year's class, and drafted a forward this year. And oh and behold, they drafted for position this year even though Hughes went on the defensive when asked about it. Should have drafted a D last year. Also Ds take longer to develop. What a waste.

All I know is I'd rather have Jiricek/Nemec-Michkov over Salf-Reinbacher.

Michkov was not an option so the question is

Slaf Reinbacher or Leonard Jiricek/Nemec ?

I prefer the 1st option

 

[FF de Mars]

i think you forgot the part where Ovy also had points against weak teams. Need to account for those too. Also, that makes it 12 in 28, not 12 in 30. If you remove the points, remove the games. 12 in 28 is 0.428 ppg and 23 in 53 is 43.3 ppg. So exactly like I said, remove those 8 points and Michkov is still really close to Ovy. Now remove whatever point Ovy got against the weakest team and Michkov is on top for most ppg, just like I said.

All this bs about real team is ridiculous. He still faced KHL opposition every night.

Come on, the team was built around him! He was showcased. Remember when Galcheyuk scored 30 in a losing season, remember RHP in pace for 2nd line production last year? And you say my arguments are bullshit. Are you seriously comparing Mitchkov to Ovy?

 

[Vachon23]

Now can we stop talking about Michkov in this thread and concentrate on Reinbacher ?

 

[dackelljuneaubulis02]

Yeah like I said, I was even underwhelmed and I loved backer and was kind of cool on Michkov lol.

I’m not going to shout anyone down. But we got a damn good one. I don’t agree with anyone who thinks he doesn’t have the upside to be a needle tilter.

Totally fine and I absolutely could be wrong. I could be swayed by needs here. I’m in the camp whose actually pretty high on our forward group and think top pairing RD was our biggest need. I’ll acknowledge my bias. Honestly though I think more posters are needs guys than they would like to acknowledge imo.

Anyways I’m pretty effing stoked