Of all the available coaching candidates, I think it's safe to narrow it down to 4 guys. Torts, Ruff, Boucher and Maurice. This organization isn't going to make a big gamble by bringing in anyone that doesn't have a track record with a certain amount of recent success and they aren't going to bring in anyone that's been out of the game for half a decade either. And they will of course conduct interviews and that sort of thing, but I think it'll come down to a coach's body of work in the past and how likely they are to have success with *this* team right now. Anybody can interview well. That's how Olczyk got the head coaching job.
Tortorella: He has the best resume of the bunch. A Cup, A Jack Adams, 2 more nominations. He teaches accountability but doesn't stifle elite offensive players. His negatives are that he probably has a short shelf-life as a coach because of his abrasiveness and his other antics.. and his negative comments about the Penguins organization might hurt his stance not only with our management but with certain players in the room.
Ruff: Probably the safest pick in the bunch. He doesn't have Torts' resume but he doesn't come with any baggage either. He's just a solid coach. He's won the Jack Adams once and been to the Finals once. His teams aren't purely run and gun and they aren't purely trap teams either, they're hybrids and they can play multiple styles and win many different ways. He seems like a good mix between a straight ball-buster and a player-friendly guy. His lack of success with a loaded Buffalo team that finally went out and spent to the cap is a concern though.
Maurice: Not the best of the bunch as far as past success but he might have an edge in that he already has an idea of what buttons to push with Malkin.. and he's also coached Jokinen and Adams previously. His teams tend to be pretty tough defensively if nothing else. He went to the Finals once in 02.
Boucher: The weakest choice of the bunch IMO. Too inexperienced prior to coming to the NHL and I think that while Tampa Bay isn't exactly a great roster they still probably underachieved the last 2 seasons under him. And while I don't care what system the team employs as long as it works, the 1-3-1 is in my opinion ineffective.
So I think with that you narrow it down to Tortorella and Ruff... And go either with the higher-risk higher-reward Torts or the safer Ruff.