In a manner of two weeks I've gone from "there's no way we will sign Duchene so I won't consider it an option" to "ok, we are rumored to be in on Duchene but I don't want to blow the budget on a mid level 1C" to "yeah signing Duchene would be pretty sweet" to "I'm going to be disappointed if we don't sign Duchene".
Signing him would do so much for this franchise.
1. Outside of injuries I feel it almost garuntees a playoff spot next season in a weaker Pacific. Playoffs = local popularity in a time where all of the other AZ franchises will be hot garbage. It could be years before the other franchises are contenders. That means years of the Yotes being on top.
2. It proves that we have an owner willing to spend and that AZ can attract top UFA. Something we have never been able to do.
3. It will help with re-signing our own players. Gally will have a much higher incentive to stay in AZ if we have success and can surround him with better players. Same for the Kellers, Crouses, Hjarlmassons, etc.
4. Stepan would potentially be our 3C. If you told me in 2016 that by 2019 Derek Stepan would be our 3C, I'd spank you.
5. If Duchene doesn't work out for cap/attitude issues we can trade him and GAIN assets. We would have signed a top end player without giving up anything. If he hates it here or doesn't fit, we can move him for real assets.