Halfway through my watch of Best Picture nominees and here are my standings.
1. West Side Story (I have no point of comparison when it comes to this version and the others that came before it, but that doesn't matter. It was clearly a passion project for Spielberg and a love letter to the movie, and that really shined through)
2. Dune (all sci-fi doesn't need to be big booms and action all the time, but it does need to nail that atmosphere to stand out. This does that very well)
3. Licorice Pizza (originally had this at number 4, but unlike the movie it overtook I was thinking about it for a couple of days after viewing. People complaining about the age gap miss the point- we all know a hot mess like Alana Kane in our lives, and if you identify with her, that's on you. Plus I like how big name actors took a back seat to the leads who are relatively new to acting)
4. The Power of the Dog (good twist at the end, but honestly it should have been about 15 minutes shorter. Not really fond of Benedict Cumberbatch faking an accent. Maybe get Ian McShane out of retirement and have him play the lead- would have been a nice callback to his Deadwood days)
5. Don't Look Up (Adam McKay needs to get his head out of his ass, apologize to Will Ferrell, and start making funny movies again. This was nominated for Best Editing as well, which... come the hell on)