Yea I would go with a mash up of the ideas stated.
If we get Trotz as Coach then all bets are off. If we get another coach I would like to see us move to a top 9 format like
@DRW204 laid out and that would get Cole to centre in a sheltered role. I prefer this because I have no interest in Scheifele’s next contract so I think this is the season Cole needs to learn the centre position and I like the idea of that happening on the 3rd line. I do see the merit of playing him in the top 6 on the wing for now until injuries occur (Lowry, Scheifele, PLD) and then moving him to centre but we need to move on from the 3rd line anchored by Lowry as our shut down unit. That quit working a few years back and I think its time to move forward out of the stone age. Nothing wrong with playing Adam in the same role but on the 4th line. I think that could actually be really effective.
We have options but in a perfect world Cole should be groomed for a top 6 centre role by 2023-24 IMO.
I'm just curious about your reasoning PS, because I know you're a heavy booster of Trotz. And right up until the Pageau trade, the Isles were running Czikas-Clutterbuck as their 3rd line. So it seems that Trotzky is a big fan of a heavy checking line. Even after the Pageau trade, Czikas was getting 14 minutes of ice time, so Trotz was running 4 lines, with Barzal being the only guy above 20 minutes. Do you think you can appease the egoes here with that kind of hockey? In Washington he ran Lars Eller at 3C, whose totals are similar to Lowry's good years, perhaps even below them.
I agree that Perfetti should be held back at C for a while. I look at him being less physically mature than Scheifele at 20, and coming off a shoulder injury. Some of the centres he could face include Faksa and Benn, who would try to drive him through the boards, maybe Landeskog (same thing) some big dogs in O'Reilly and Schenn, some hard checking centres in Nashville, and then you have the skaters like Mc Jesus, and Mac Crosby and I don't really see Cole matching up in any way with those guys.
Then I look at the guy who has been developed as a centre here in Winnipeg, David Gustafsson. When the Moose season started last year it was Gus centering Perfetti if I am not mistaken. He was earmarked for the 4th line this year after Nash was moved to waivers, but couldn't stay healthy.
So going into this season I think that Perfetti's most successful spot would be building on the primarily offensive zone line with Connor and Dubois. And more PP time to build up some confidence.
As for Scheifele, I wonder how much a healthy Blake Wheeler affects his performance. Because Scheif has always been Scheif. Great offensive instincts, poor defensive awareness. But Wheeler as he continues to slow, needs to be the guy that can take care of the defensive zone, allowing Scheifele to have success in the other end of the rink.
I'd be really surprised regardless of coach, if Chevy's game plan isn't
Connor-Dubois-Perfetti
Ehlers-Scheifele-Wheeler
?-Lowry-Appleton
?-Gustafsson-?
And so there's 3 question marks, one of them probably goes to Barron, you've got Svetchnikov, Harkins, Reichel, Toninato competing, Torgersson as an outside shot, and probably somebody else brought in.