BoneDocUK
Recovering hockey fandoc
- Oct 1, 2015
- 7,021
- 15,155
Keeping them in the minors long after they are ready is what I mean by over-ripening. I think they become discouraged, resentful and slip into bad habits eventually.
When they are "ready", really ready, they need to be given their chance. They should not have to wait for an injury.
Yep. Not every player needs to finish out a junior career and then toil in the AHL to “season” before they are ready for the show. And players do not stop developing in the NHL — good, smart players who can be trusted with the basics learn on the job, and should be challenged at the highest level they are capable of handling well.
Part of he problem with the Jets has been the rigid division of lines into scoring, checking, and energy, leaving just 6 slots open for “skill” players, with vets in Stats and Wheeler locked into two of them, and four of the team’s best younger players rightfully taking up the other 4. That leaves a spot on the Lowry line and maybe one or two more on the 4th, where the tie always has and always will go to the vet — whoever he has, and however well he plays.
I don’t see a big problem in Perfetti starting the year in the AHL, and maybe being released to play at the WJHC, but he’s already so good and so quick off the mark that I doubt he will have many challenges there by mid-season. If he’s capable of out-playing someone on the Jets, why should he sit in the A?
Heinola offers a different challenge. He’s a very competitive kid who, I suspect, knows just how good he is, and will not relish spending another year dominating the A, so maybe he slots in with an injury — Samberg stays where he is, IMO.
The point is that players who are ready aren’t necessarily going to benefit from playing at a level or 2 below their capabilities, so they can be viewed as “having earned it.” And there’s no hard and fast rule that I know of about what age a player is most likely to help their team. As a friend of mine said the other day: “Who would you rather have on your team — 18-20 or 21-23 YO Patrik Laine?”