Player Discussion Cayden Primeau Part II
- Thread starter ahmedou
- Start date
Sam de Mtl
Registered User
- Oct 11, 2021
- 1,376
- 2,482
montreal
Go Habs Go
why did you think that would have been the best move over just putting Allen on waivers as there's noting to lose there?
Leon Lucius Black
Registered User
- Nov 5, 2007
- 16,033
- 6,263
I agree sending Allen down would've made more sense, however given how highly Hughes spoke of Allen's leadership and how good he was in the locker room, I couldn't have pictured him ever sending Allen to Laval.
JuJu Mobb
Registered User
- Dec 9, 2009
- 2,990
- 3,391
Nobody talks about this guy anymore. I had to dig this thread from the abyss.
He had some good stats last year and was good in his first exhibition game against Philly.
He had some good stats last year and was good in his first exhibition game against Philly.
HuGort
Registered User
If Primeau has good season going to make things interesting. With Dobes in the wings and Fowler turning pro late this season.
JuJu Mobb
Registered User
- Dec 9, 2009
- 2,990
- 3,391
Canadienna
Registered User
- Jan 27, 2015
- 13,035
- 18,432
Can Dobes take his job this year?
I think it's clear who has had the better camp. Not sure if it's worth waiving and likely losing Primeau though.
I think it's clear who has had the better camp. Not sure if it's worth waiving and likely losing Primeau though.
Primeau is the backup this year, and will be traded next year to make space for Dobes. Fowler will be the #1 in the AHL for a couple of years replacing Dobes.
WeThreeKings
Demidov is a HAB
Primeau is a journeyman NHL back up. Which is still fantastic for a 7th round pick. I've always mentioned the hitch in his Lateral movements which really hasn't smoothened out enough at the pro level.
Athletically he's pretty average. He needs to be able to read the play at a high level and I just haven't seen that consistently.
The PK wasn't great but man he wasn't really in the right area code for any of it.
Athletically he's pretty average. He needs to be able to read the play at a high level and I just haven't seen that consistently.
The PK wasn't great but man he wasn't really in the right area code for any of it.
To put it bluntly, he has had a very weak camp.
I thought he looked servicable in his first half-game. But tonight (well the half the game I saw), his mind wasn't there at all.
I am not so sure about Monty, I have watched him steadily improve since his arrival and he is now just hitting his prime. He handles the puck well, moves very well in his crease and most importantly he isn't phased by being a French Canadian goalie playing for the Habs. I like him.
Agreed
Hopefully Dobes and/or Fowler can prove to be long term solutions in goal. I have no faith in Monty or Primeau
HuGort
Registered User
Oh I agree Monty improved a lot and I don't expect him to be replaced before the end of his current contract, but I think he's getting replaced eventually or falls back to backup status.
Yep at the very least Monty ends up being a solid back up. He will get replaced eventually if Dobes and Fowler continue their upward trajectories.
Habby4Life
First pick overall goes to the Montreal Canadiens
- Nov 12, 2008
- 4,477
- 4,261
I’m not sure if they should even worry if Primeau is picked up on waivers. He is so replaceable via a UFA signing.
Primeau is 25 now. Around the same age Montembault established himself as a backup at 23. Now at 27 Montembault is a solid #1 goalie. Both goalies are 6’3” 215lbs, but Primeau looks smaller due to his position. Primeau every time he lets a goal it seems like he loses confidence follows by multiple goals. It could be psychological, I don’t know I’m not a doctor.
Anyhow I can tell Primeau is no Carey Price, but I don’t think Primeau is an NHL goalie for some reason. Reminds me of Jim Carry or Andrew Raycroft back in the day.
As for Dobes it’s too early to tell. The guy is 6’4” 210lbs a little taller but looks huge in goal. Like there’s no room to shoot. He covers the net like Carey Price. His positioning is like Pekka Rinne.
What I’m saying is Primeau plays like he’s 6’ even though he’s 6’3”. Dobes is 6’4” but covers the net like he’s 6’6”.
On the other hand Juuse Saros who’s 5’11” covers the net like he’s 6’3”. Some goalies just looks bigger than others.
Anyhow I can tell Primeau is no Carey Price, but I don’t think Primeau is an NHL goalie for some reason. Reminds me of Jim Carry or Andrew Raycroft back in the day.
As for Dobes it’s too early to tell. The guy is 6’4” 210lbs a little taller but looks huge in goal. Like there’s no room to shoot. He covers the net like Carey Price. His positioning is like Pekka Rinne.
What I’m saying is Primeau plays like he’s 6’ even though he’s 6’3”. Dobes is 6’4” but covers the net like he’s 6’6”.
On the other hand Juuse Saros who’s 5’11” covers the net like he’s 6’3”. Some goalies just looks bigger than others.
