I would argue that Price's composure was a myth, there is and always has been some weird disconnect with him that people mistake for composure. He was terrible for his final 5 seasons with glimpses of his talent. He was huge in the Cup Finals run but was largely to blame for almost missing the playoffs. He rescued his 2018-19 season with an incredible finish after being the primary cause for sinking the season with an atrocious first half.
I will always have a soft spot for him as he was a legend at his peak but he mentally caved in too many times in his career including in the playoffs. What we saw on draft day was a glimpse of what has always been there. When things are going well he is able to disconnect from the pressure but the opposite happens when he is off and it has always been an ugly site.
Hopefully Carey finds peace and can enjoy life without the pressure that was/is too much for him to handle. He seems like a very kind introverted person who was appallingly shoved into the spotlight and the coping mechanism that most of us mistook for composure was breaking down for the world to see. My heart went out to him in Nashville and hopefully the organization will just allow him to fade into obscurity with his family where he is more comfortable and at ease with the world.
I'm not bias at all no way, but I would argue the opposite. I'd say he was as composed as can be for a goalie.
Pressure wise he was always at his best when the games mattered the most. Be it WJC, Olympics, Playoffs, etc - he was always money. You could see it on the ice too. He was so in control of the game and his team always fed off of that. Truly a sight to watch even if the end result didn't go his way.
His regular seasons are wonky yeah. Not all of them tho he had some really good ones too, but lots of stinkers his last 5 like you said. Really makes it tough to fairly judge his career considering how good he was when the stakes were high. But i also feel had we iced better teams during those years, we'd also see Price match that and elevate his game too.
Guy was just a stoic in the crease. Always thought he was the perfect guy for the CH. His composure was the least of worries me personally