LOL who has better numbers away from Pettersson and Miller? You're talking 2 top30 NHL forwards and we know Brock is a scorer not a checker and furthermore the 3rd part of that Miller line the last 2yrs has been Pearson and DiGuiseppe is that another prop player along with poor defense behind them?
Boeser was a competent member of the lotto line you're stuck in a sample size with him hurt and going through mental anguish and it's hard to give him these excuses but until this year i dont think he ever realized how tenuous his career could be and he would be unwanted. His wrist and back has made him adjust his game to being a better playmaker and when/if his wrist can get stronger then he should be able to rack 25-30goals
A motivated Brock will be a decent top 6 scorer next year and is a better bet than Garland or Beauvillier to produce in the top6 going forward. Of course his contract is hefty and a deterrent but it's 2 yrs on a prime aged player who has chemistry and is a glue guy with both Miller and Pettersson
This the kind of thinking that has left the team screwed over, year after year. We've watched Boeser for at least the last couple of years look awful. He's been too slow to generate anything on his own. Most of his scoring is from garbage goals around the net or assists on the PP. (which he has more messed up with his poor passing than anything and he has been a distant second in deserving that role over Kuzmenko) There has been nothing dynamic or upper level in his game or his scoring for years. Yes, if he plays with Miller or Pettersson, he'll get some stats but very, very little comes from anything he is creating.
His defense is mind-blowingly bad. He has been even worse than Horvat on the back check. (he never gets back to strip the puck), his point coverage is likely the worst on the team and he is one of the worst puck watchers in League IMO.
His lack of mobility and overall lack of speed also makes his transition game weak. He simply does not play a 200 foot game and never really has.
When Boeser was drafted, scouts acknowledged he was a poor skater - that's why he fell to later in the first round. Ultimately, that view was borne out even though, at first, his shot and short bursts of speed seemed to overcome that short coming. However, as the injuries have mounted and the speed of the League increased, Boeser has increasingly struggled.
What we're left with is a suspect top 6 player who can't play anywhere else but top 6 in your lineup. I mean Boudreau got so frustrated, he let Boeser drift down the line up but that only emphasized how bad he was without top end support from players like Pettersson. Only when he was returned to be held up by players like Miller did he again show anything.
Yet, in spite of what we've been people live in some sort of idle hope that with a little more effort, little more conditioning, little more chance that Boeser will reemerge as player he seemed at one time. It's this living on hope rather than living in reality that has so sunk the team in the past. For years, we watched the idiot Virtanen mangle every chance he was given and then be told that he only needed more time. Rather than cut our losses and acknowledge the obvious, we carried on with a player that was never going anywhere.
And so it is with Boeser. Boeser has been given ample opportunity to turn his game around. In fact, I would say he's been babied and given far too many excuses. And we are at point, IMO where a decision has to be made. And hope is not a decision - instead it's away of not making a decision. Boeser is too slow and has lost most of the sting on his shot. And he is costing 6.4 on the cap. That is too much. If we sit back and wait for him to show up at camp drastically improved, we are IMO once again avoiding reallocating resources to someone potentially better or to any area of the club in more need of change. And, at that point, it will be too late to do anything about it.
In truth, Boeser should never have been re-signed last summer. It is likely the worst mistake the present regime has made. That cap space was infinitely more valuable and still is. This mistake needs to rectified ASAP. If we can trade Boeser great (even if we have to add - and the fact he probably do is proof enough of why Boeser should be moved). If not, do the difficult but right thing - BUY HIM OUT. It is the hard decision but good organizations are capable of making those hard decisions.