I know this won’t be an exciting comparison for those who don’t appreciate how good Tomas Hertl is, but Carlsson reminds me so much of Hertl at the same age but with better speed and much better vision and playmaking.
This kid is a future star, in my opinion, if he works on his clear weaknesses, and the things he needs to improve on the most will improve with age and maturity as long as Carlsson puts the effort in. When Hertl was in his teens and early 20’s, one of his weaknesses was that he lost his balance too easily and went down under pressure. He went to work on his lower body strength and balance and now he’s one of the hardest players in the league to push off the puck. When Carlsson gets his man strength and puts in the gym work to develop a Hertl-like strength on his skates, he’ll be Malkin-esque. The other thing Carlsson needs to work on is his pass/shoot decision-making, which is Joe Thornton-like right now. He’s a playmaker through and through, but he’ll become a much more dangerous offensive threat if opponents have to defend both the shot and pass.
I’m probably one of few who has Carlsson above Fantilli right now.