Confirmed Trade: [BUF/VGK] Jack Eichel, c.'23 3rd for Alex Tuch, Peyton Krebs, c.'22 1st (Top10 protected), c.'23 2nd
- Thread starter 5cotland
- Start date
- Status
Don't see how the Sabres could have gotten more than this for an injured Eichel. Pretty mediocre return which most ppl saw coming.
2023FriendshipTour
Flams
No doubt.. Pretty good return for a player that has no guarantees on health. It was rumored he would be back after the Olympic break this morning.
NiagaraKraken
Registered User
Nico Cauzuki
Registered User
How much more return did you think the Sabres would get for an injured disgruntled player at $10M/yr? I'm surprised they made out as well as they did.
Speatleysson
Registered User
Buffalo made out like bandits in this trade. This will be like the erik Karlsson trade 2.0.
1) Buffalo was brutal WITH eichel; yet performs way better without him. Huge red flag in my opinion.. especially with rumors swirling that Eichel is a drama queen
2) losing Tuch will hurt vegas more than they think; depth guys like that help you win. The rest of the return in Krebs + picks is very solid.
3) eichel is a phenomenal talent, but he'll never be the same after the surgery.
I know I'm going to get flamed for this, thats fine. I'll PM you in a few years to say I told you so.
1) Buffalo was brutal WITH eichel; yet performs way better without him. Huge red flag in my opinion.. especially with rumors swirling that Eichel is a drama queen
2) losing Tuch will hurt vegas more than they think; depth guys like that help you win. The rest of the return in Krebs + picks is very solid.
3) eichel is a phenomenal talent, but he'll never be the same after the surgery.
I know I'm going to get flamed for this, thats fine. I'll PM you in a few years to say I told you so.
Jim Bob
RIP RJ
Rochester, like plenty of US cities, are still dealing with the affects of redlining.
And visiting a place and living there are two different things entirely.
And we can throw articles around for a long time...
Why Rochester, New York Is The Best Small City in America for Vegans
Obviously the futures part (Krebs and the 1st) better pan out.
Under rated part of the trade is the 2022 1st. Vegas is out of a playoff spot right now. Not even in a wild card position. In the "weak" Pacific Division, Edmonton and Calgary are looking very good. Lots of competition for the last spot.
Buffalo now have 3 1sts in a strong 2022 draft.
i said rational. The sabres were never getting 3 blue chips for eichel when you factor in injury and cap hit. With 8 teams bidding before all the details maybe they get a better offer. Once the news came out a lot of teams wanted to get in the talks, but their doctors said NO to ADR they had no choice but to be out. The surgery shrunk the market and is still a big risk for Vegas now.
Skinnyjimmy08
WorldTraveler
- Mar 30, 2012
- 22,906
- 12,741
Rabid Ranger
2 is better than one
If Eichel gets his surgery and it's a success and he comes back the same player he was before the ailment it's a clear win for Vegas but there's risk. Not sure why all the hand wringing over the assets exchanged due to those circumstances. The bigger shame is it took so long.
Awesome return? You were asking for WAY more in the summer … why the change of opinion?
SeanMoneyHands
Registered User
- Apr 18, 2019
- 15,275
- 14,614
Matt Tkachuk was never offered. Made up by Weekes. Otherwise Adams would have to be draindead not to instantly accept the Flames offer.
I’m sorry, but how in the hell did Treliving not beat that? Huge miss.
Jim Bob
RIP RJ
Everyone that was paying attention knew that. Even a large segment of the Sabres fanbase.
I'm surprised that Adams' patience netted Krebs and not more bad cap back.
North Cole
♧ Lem
- Jan 22, 2017
- 11,841
- 13,523
Okay, but at some point I think people need to separate what fans want from reality. Judging the actual finalized trade against some monopoly money HF discussions doesn't make sense to me. Not all of those guys you named seem to be the same level anyways and I don't see why BUF would want Dumba.
tsujimoto74
Moderator
- May 28, 2012
- 30,624
- 23,394
Pick is top 10 protected, but if it winds up there (slim chance, imo), then all of the picks just slide 1 year later without protection. So Buffalo would get Vegas' 2023 1st and 2024 2nd while giving up its 2024 3rd.
Poppy Whoa Sonnet
J'Accuse!
- Jan 24, 2007
- 7,619
- 8,295
Yeah Buffalo basically did the best they could imo. The only thing in retrospect I think was a major mistake was not letting him get the surgery he wanted and forcing them to dump him for whatever they could. However I'm not an expert on the risks involved there.
You can make the case Buffalo could have done a three way deal if Calgary was dangling Tkachuk but he wasn't gonna stay in Buffalo long term so he didn't make sense as an acquisition target.
Theodore450
Registered User
- Sep 10, 2013
- 4,679
- 2,407
Amazing how so many posters said the Sabres were asking for far too much wanting 4 1st round equivalents for Jack, and are now saying receiving 3 1st round equivalents and a 2nd for Jack and a 3rd is not enough. Where is the middle ground then?
This is a decent return for an injured star who was never going to play for the franchise again. Everyone knew the return would be quantity for quality. A lot of the most reasonable offers had similar pieces moving (Roster player, high end prospect, picks). Also there don't seem to be any conditions tied to Jack's future health, games played etc which is a win for Buffalo.
This is a decent return for an injured star who was never going to play for the franchise again. Everyone knew the return would be quantity for quality. A lot of the most reasonable offers had similar pieces moving (Roster player, high end prospect, picks). Also there don't seem to be any conditions tied to Jack's future health, games played etc which is a win for Buffalo.
Chiarelli
Registered User
- Jan 27, 2019
- 5,001
- 6,994
There was actually a few Buffalo fans saying it would take Seider AND Raymond to get Eichel
As a neutral fan, I think Vegas is making a huge mistake. They've taken a really good team with a lot of energy and drive and traded most of it away to end up with a team of high salaries and aging players. Eichel doesn't necessarily fit the aging part, but if the surgery has any complications, he might seem like an older player.
Given all the moves they've made since they came into the league their first season, I don't think they have what it takes now to win a cup before their first tear down and rebuild. Their window is closed.
I think the Sabres didn't get everything they probably wanted, but a clean sheet from the Eichel situation is probably the biggest win of the whole thing, so I like that it is over for them and they can move forward with what looks like a young and exciting team.
Given all the moves they've made since they came into the league their first season, I don't think they have what it takes now to win a cup before their first tear down and rebuild. Their window is closed.
I think the Sabres didn't get everything they probably wanted, but a clean sheet from the Eichel situation is probably the biggest win of the whole thing, so I like that it is over for them and they can move forward with what looks like a young and exciting team.
- Status
