DominicT
Registered User
I hate trying to judge anyone i dont know so i try to stay away from personal stuff other than to say who my favorite posters are. I hope dom knows hes one of my top 5 favorites
I never want to single out someones credibility when i say teams arent alowed to tamper with other teams players as far as rumor leaks go... or if i say draft success is below 50% successful outside the top 5 picks...
So my blanket statement... that all insiders and all draft experts should have humility because they are all wrong more often.
But never would i say i dont like the inside info... or i dont value prospect scouting. And absolutely i think some insiders and experts come across more credible than others
Im neither an insider nor an expert. But i try to be a student of the info i can get my hands on. Without people like dom sharing their inside and expertise, people like me would be basing our own hunches on garbage.
I just wondered why dom said id be here arguing right and wrong about prospect evaluation because thats someting ive never done in my 15 years here
Mike. Go back and read your own posts. Right and wrong come up a lot. I don' think the draft is as easy as right or wrong as it is hit and miss. And there is a difference.
You can make an argument for any player drafted in any spot at the time of the draft. And 99.9 percent of the time those arguments are correct on draft day.
But from June 30 onwards it' up to the player to become what what was seen in him. Often players don't achieve that. But that is on the player and not the team.
As for inside stuff I have told you a million times that GM's are talking almost daily. I have admitted in the past I get no info from the Bruins and it comes from outside the team.
I remember vividly the crap I took on Twitter and a little here when I tweeted the Bruins were preparing a buyout and an offersheet. Two days later the buyout happened but not the offer sheet. For reasons I don' have to explain to anyone. Then I had to go on our podcast and somewhat defend myself?
I had surgery last week. I come home to find a nasty message waiting for me. And I did something I never do. I sent Dan almost a complete list of my contacts. Even he was impressed.
So forgive me for not buying into the argument you have been making for a long time now. Just because someone says team x is talking to team y and then nothing happens doesn'
Change the fact that they talked.
As for the draft and prospects, I can honestly say I have at least one scout from every NHL team that follows my work. As a matter of fact, 3 Bruins. Why? Because I cover a league that they don't get to see. And I know the teams with multiple scouts that do, well they are the guys trying to be successful and knowing every possible player they can.
Anyway, I will leave it at that. Things are not always as black and white as you want them to be or try to make it out to be.