God, I can't believe I got trolled into putting these rosters up. If you really believe 2008 is better than 2013 then speak now so I don't have to read your opinion any longer
He's a mediocre top pairing defenseman. Hardly sucks. Context is important and you clearly lack it
prospects aren't any better. it's easy to bash those busts now but at the time they were ranked just as well as our current crop.
the D was better on paper and yeah, our top 2 forward lines look better now (well, just kessel), but goaltending is a wash and the on ice results are worse.