Pretty worried about this. I know Makar is amazing but he isnt particularly good on the defensive side of things. Seems like a lot for not even getting the 7th or 8th year.
He's fine defensively and he'll only get better.
His main issue is just inconsistency. Sometimes it looks like he's reading the play very well and staying in good position. Other times he might lose his man or look a tad confused.
I think it's because he's always thinking multiple steps ahead. Trying to read the ice with both an offensive and defensive mindset, so he'll know what to do if the puck comes to him.
He always battles hard though physically in the D zone, which I always like to see. As opposed to offensive D men that just shadow their assignment all over the ice putting in the minimum effort, and saving their energy for offense. Cale puts in the effort defensively.
Ironing out that inconsistency is just part of the process for young defenseman though. He's a very good bet to get better defensively, because he's such a hard worker, who's committed to the details of the game.