1) Crosby
2) Hughes
3) Zibanejad
4) Aho
5) Barzal
6) Fantilli
7) D. Strome
8) Frost
They probably should've went with Kuznetsov and Couturier over Strome and Frost, would've been more interesting.
Even if Hughes outscores him by a c*** hair, think I'd still go with Crosby at #1 right now for his overall game. That could change quickly though. Zibanejad on his game, I think you could make a fair argument for #2 for the same reasons. Kills penalties, PP, competent on FOs, he does everything. Aho is a similar mold. Think I'd still have to put Hughes ahead of them though. I'm half tempted to put Fantilli above the rest of them. Bedard/Fantilli could shape up to be like McDavid/Eichel. When Eichel first got to Buffalo there wasn't a ton of help at wing. I'd fully expect Fantilli to get a chance to play with guys like Gaudreau, Laine and K. Johnson. He could be a star right out of the gate.
Honestly if we ever get a chance to see 19-20 Zibanejad again he could be the #1 guy on that list bringing everything that he does. That was a guy that year that was 7th in the entire league in terms of points per game, 5th for centers. A whopping 108 point pace. Him and Panarin were MACHINES that season. As much of bozo Quinn was, he did try to get these guys to play a more direct N/S game. And the numbers speak for themselves.. its no coincidence that season both Zibanejad and Panarin were on pace for the most shots they've ever had in their career. For reference, Panarin was on pace for ~250 shots. Zibanejad was on pace for ~300 shots. An average season they don't come close to those totals. They need to get back to that. Those both would've been career highs. Pastrnak had over 400 shots this year. A lot of the best players in the league hover near that 300 number or more. Both Panarin and Zibanejad have outstanding shots. They need to get back to those shot totals. They are much much better players when they're playing more direct. As much as I've been disappointed in Panarin, I'm looking forward to seeing if Laviolette can push the right buttons for him and the rest of them. A number of these guys have much much more to give