There's a lot that can be said about the contract to Draisaitl, but to pretend like he and McDavid aren't arguably the best players in the league is a bit goofy...And to be fair to Draisaitl, he might be even more clutch in the playoffs than McDavid, which adds to his value (or any team planning to make the playoffs). Discounts are nice and great, but NHL players are handsomely underpaid athletes.
Agreed.
In the last 6 years, Drai has finished 2nd, 4th, 4th, 2nd, 4th, and 14th in goals. Taking this sample as a whole, he is 2nd in goals and 7th in even strength goals over the last 6 years.
In those same 6 years, Drai has finished 4th, 1st, 2nd, 4th, 2nd, and 7th in points. Taking this sample as a whole, he is 2nd in points and 3rd in even strength points in the last 6 years.
Does he benefit from having McDavid as a teammate? Absolutely. But he plays about two-thirds of his even strength minutes away from McDavid. Over the last few years, MacKinnon has played a
substantially higher number of his minutes with Makar and Rants than Drai has with McDavid. Matthews has played a
substantially higher number of minutes with Marner. Looking at the last 3 years (what I'm limited to as a non-paying customer at Natural Stat Trick), Drai has about 1200 5 on 5 minutes with McDavid. Mac has 2700 minutes with Rants and 2200 minutes with Makar. Matthews has 2000 minutes with Marner. McDavid is better than these guys, but is he so much better that 1200 minutes with him pads the stats more than 2000+ minutes with Rants/Marner/Makar? I'd argue no.
Drai has absolutely produced at an elite level both at even strength and away from McDavid. McDavid being on the ice for some of his minutes and drawing defensive matchups on another line certainly contributes to Drai's production. But it isn't like Drai is the only elite player who benefits from having elite teammates.
It is also worth noting that his playoff performances have been incredible. In the last 3 years, he is top 5 in the playoffs in all of goals, assists, points, even strength points, power play points, power play goals, 5 on 5 goals, 5 on 5 assists, and 5 on 5 points. He is 2nd in most those categories. He's top 5 in 5 on 5 points per 60 as well (minimum 150 minutes), so it isn't just racking up gaudy totals due to a games played advantage. He's been an absolute playoff stud.
I genuinely don't see an argument that he isn't a no-doubt top 5 center in the game.