That's legitimately shocking.
But the Conn Smythe is a trophy for a 2 month time frame. Maybe even just the Finals MVP. You don't have to be, what should be, the elite of the elite to win thar. The HoF needs a higher bar than the Conn Smythe. Or even the Hart.
Sometimes it does feel like the HoF has gotten diluted, but then I know that I'm not a good judge of that stuff. Outside of the obviously all-time level players, who match or break significant records, or are just an overall dominant presence on the ice, I would tend toward no on any edge cases. To me, Kopitar, obviously a Kings HoF guy, but a league wide elite of the elite HoF player? I guess if Luongo is going, and he's got the pedigree(not drafted that high for nothing), and a solid career, but HoF? I'd say the same for Kopitar.
Same with Doughty. Considering all the criticisms we've had for him over 14 years, is that HoF worthy? A small part of the game, but getting his shots blocked. Crosby is famous for, at least allegedly, working on bits of his game every year that he felt were insufficient. It's what keeps him near the top every year. 34 this year, and still on pace for 100pts. Doughty, seems to shoot the puck the same way every year. Crosby, in addition to the point totals, has that feel to him. A little bit more special than the rest for a long time. He's worked at it. Is that Doughty? If the HoF is the extraordinary club, I would say no. If it's the quite good club, then sure.