Sad thing is we HAD both, no choice required. Then Blake entered the chat.
What a time to be a Kings fan.
I think the #1 pre-requisite to finishing a rebuild is having at least one star, but ideally two stars that you can confidently say are the backbone of your franchise. The Kings had this with Kopitar and Doughty, a team like Vancouver has it with Petterssen and Hughes. I don't know if Kings have one player at that type of level, I think Clarke could maybe get there but it's tough to know because we have such a small NHL games to go off of with this ridiculous slow cook strategy of the Kings, if I had to guess maybe he's just a level below guys like Makar, Hughes and Fox
But the Kings actually did do a pretty effective job of building up secondary pieces. Despite being an early Favor truther, I still am not sure the offense will keep up enough where he is Doughty good, although if this is the norm he very well could be a franchise d-man on the level of Doughty, but I am still a little skeptical the offense will hold. I was not a big Vilardi fan mostly due to skating, but he has definitely developed into what is going to be a very solid 2nd line winger for a contending team, ditto with Byfield except I think his ceiling is as a 1st line winger, not a franchise player but a useful one, I wouldn't say the value has been great for where he went, but he's looking better than he did a year ago. Anderson is a really solid 2nd pair defensive stopper, could easily be a Willie Mitchell type on a contending team one day.
Faber (Top 20'ish d-man)
Clarke (Top 20'ish d-man)
Byfield (1st line winger)
Anderson (2nd line shut down defenseman)
Vilardi (2nd line winger)
Obviously the Turcotte miss, getting basically nothing from a Top 5 pick hurts, as does the Bjornfot and Kupari whiffs, but no rebuild is perfect, even the last one survived that generations Turcotte and Bjornfot (Hickey and Teubert). But you have those 5 names and then you add probably a similar caliber prospect in 2022 (there were no stars), which further helps with those secondary pieces. But it's the 2023 draft that I think is going to be the one where we look back and say "Damn, we needed to be picking in the Top 5". Bedard really not much more needs to be said, if you ended up with him it changes the entire course of your franchise for 15-20 years, but even Carlsson and Fantilli very likely give you the crown jewel #1 center that Blake was so desperately looking for with all those picks from 2017-2020. I don't think Will Smith is a 100% lock franchise 1C like the other guys, but it's certainly very possible he is that kind of player, and even if he's not he's still the highest ceiling prospect you have, and then you have Michkov who has the Kucherov type talent level who was an option to, the type of guy who can lead your team in scoring for a decade.
With as far out as draft years are projected, and with what the Kings should have known from watching their own guys play in the system it should have been painfully apparent that they lacked those couple of pre-req type of players you need to have to end the rebuild. That is what is just so frustrating with the awful decisions made by this management team. Not only do you miss out on being able to draft the generational superstar, or one of the other 4 franchise players in 2023, the need to add older players to appease Drew Doughty caused you to lose probably the best player the Kings have drafted since Doughty, and a guy who will probably be able to challenge for 25-35 goals a season.
Fiala is a fun player to watch, Danault has been a great leader and joy to watch, Gavrikov also. But these guys are short term fixes and the guys we lost out on either through trades or not finishing a proper rebuild and picking high are going to be NHL forces for another 10-15 years.