Hextall never should've been fired in Philly. He built the core of that team. He was overly patient, perhaps, but if I'm the Pens he's one of the top candidates. It would be juicy to see one of the greatest ever Flyers lead the Pens to another Cup.
I was a huge fan of Hextall's vision, taking 30 years of Holmgren/Clarke assest mismanagment and turning that barren wasteland of a farm system into a fertile valley. Flyers will be reapoing the rewards for years, he's got a great eye. Provorov, Konecky, Frost, Patrick, Hart, Oscar Radcliffe, and esp Phil Myers, an undrafted stud who should be a top pairing with Provy for years. However, what got him fired was his totalitarian attitude. He refused to see his flaws, wouldn't consider that his idea, decision was not the right one, wouldn't even talk to it. It was his word, period. Not flexible in any area of his realm. Wouldn't fire the PP coach over 4 years of failure. Didn't always see that his patience, closing in of 5 years, could have been tweaked. Was harsh on players, lockerroom stuff (The players couldn’t eat pizza. Alumni weren’t allowed to use the locker room among other quirks) Had a bit of a mean streak and could be downright nasty, according to some of the reporters. They'd be around at practices, etc, and hear him barking at staff, workers, etc.
Bottom fell out when he refused to fire Hakstol, who should have never been hired or given a 5 year deal with no pro experience. He couldn't see that his first hire as a coach, was a failure. Firing him would have been ad admittance that he'd erred. He couldn't have that, so he wouldn't fire him, even as the team fell apart under Haks extremely abrasive demeanor ( and was awful period as a coach) He held out and held out and management finally had to step in and fire him, so they could fire Hakstol.
I hope he learned from the experience, and going forward, as a GM understand that not waivering from your desire to be right all the time, is a huge flaw. He needs to understand accepting adapatation is not loss of control but the ability to grow.