Larkin is bottom tier 1C and Seider has lost some luster in the last 2 years. Copp and JTC are 2 bad contracts...then you have the Chiarot, Petry, Perron...Fabbri, Ghost, Holl...
Yikes.
I really, really don't like how Yzerman built this team. Classic case of not being patient enough with your rebuild and trying to patch holes way too early.
He had a career year in points last season (79) so I have no idea what you're talking about him losing "some luster the last 2 years."
And he's not a "bottom tier" 1C. He's a legit top line pivot, just because they're not a MacKinnon/McDavid/Hughes-type franchise talent doesn't mean they're "bottom tier." You can still build a winner around a center like that. If Kasper ends up being better then they're in REALLY good shape going forward. And mind you I'm actually not that big a Larkin fan.
You also have a ridiculously high bar when it comes to "bad contracts." I agree the Chiarot deal is not good but I tell ya what, that contract is already aging better than Manson's, and the players in terms of age and cap hit are nearly identical. But really? Ghost? That's a completely manageable cap hit and is for one f***ing year. C'mon man...
JTC got the going market rate for a good 3C/utility guy. Copp is making similar coin, and I'm guessing one of them will get moved if cap space becomes an issue.
This really isn't that different from what Yzerman did in Tampa. He signed and traded for veteran players there too, it wasn't a full-on tank job like the type you always seem to advocate for.
I'm curious...has any team tanked and rebuilt the way you like? Because I'm not sure any team has done it the way you want it and been successful.