Love the discussion...and yes, you make arguments that I could easily make as well because a rebuild is a very tempting option...especially when most fans have grown to dislike the veterans as much as they do in LA.
I personally think Luc's comments were idiotic and counterproductive. Even in a rebuild you have to hold everyone accountable. Who is accountable in the organization right now? Blake/Luc? Doesn't seem like it. TM? How can he be accountable without a GM committed to giving him a decent roster? Players? Not a chance.
So now you have an organ-eye-zation that is developing and furthering a losing and unaccountable culture. They are right back to 2006. And worse than that the Kings are going to try to infuse young players into a culture of losing while enjoying every distraction that living at the beach has to offer. I'm not a big fan of Dean Lombardi (to say the least) but the one thing he changed was the culture of the team. That is now totally lost. And once lost, it will be hard to bring back. Talent alone will not do it. Everyone has to be driven by success and offer no excuses for losing. Luc's comments only fed into that narrative. Shame on him!
I'd rather have ownership who demands success; a GM who demands success; a coach who demands success; and players who demand success of themselves!! And most of all, FANS who demand success. Otherwise, it doesn't matter how long you rebuild...you'll be a losing franchise.
Maybe it starts at the very top with AEG and Staples and the Lakers. The Lakers have been a train wreck for the better part of a decade with no end in sight. Their "rebuild" has been a disaster (something Kings fans should think about). None of the teams making Staples their home (kings, lakers, and clippers) have had any playoff success for at least the last 4 years. That has to be killing revenues and creating a culture of chaos and losing at the very top within Staples/AEG. If ownership will accept a losing culture, why shouldn't we expect the GM, coach, and players to do so as well. Right now, it seems like there are too many fans who are giving everyone in the organ-eye-zation a pass. That is wrong. If the fans don't demand success then ownership will simply continue to take your money with no consequences. Who are the suckers then?
I appreciate your point of view as well since I was also of the same mindset until I saw a rebuild turn into the happiest moments of my life. Hell...I wanted Giguere when his contract was up with the Ducks. I wanted them to sign Lecavalier, Drury...anybody to stop the losing.
T-Mac is supposed to hold the players that are on the team accountable for their play: adding or not adding players doesn't change that fact. If he takes basically the same roster and they improve by 10-12 points, that is a step forward, right? 81-83 points with the same team when 90 points got you a playoff spot this season seems like a step forward: especially if they play with some structure and effort can't be questioned like it so often was last season.
Lombardi's culture didn't begin the second he set foot in LA and he also introduced young players into a losing environment. Kings picked 4th/2nd/5th three years in a row. The whole point of giving T-Mac a five year deal and "tossing away" this season is to reset everything and try to rebuild a culture that began to erode with Voynov, was made worse with the Richards situation and captaincy change until it finally cratered with the players not wanting to put forth the effort required under Sutter Hockey, ultimately leading to his and Lombardi's dismissal. I agree that it is lost. If they are back to 2006 again, why go after more vets when 2006 was when a full rebuild started?
They are back at square one except they aren't in a full rebuild since they have 11 and 8, hence the "retool on the fly" that many on here have advocated. It isn't a complete tear down since the foundation has NMCs so it is more of a remodel. There is no quick fix for this upcoming season and it is probably prudent to see how each player--young and old alike--plays for their new coach with the long contract. T-Mac will be integral to instilling the proper culture and accountability. As for Blake's role in accountability, not giving these big dollar players additional help after crapping the bed is the most he can do to make them accountable this side of trading them. They shit the bed: they clean the sheets. Make those sheets nice and clean again, maybe Blake gets you a nice sleep number mattress and has some youngsters that can help make the bed for you on top of it all.
They expect the existing vets to be better next season. I think that is expecting some accountability. If 11/8/32/77 aren't killing it, some 4-5 defenseman isn't going to matter. They had a pretty good one in Muzzin last year and it meant jack shit. With the contracts already in place on this team, they should expect to win games and there shouldn't be any excuses. I also don't think AEG accepts a losing culture since they canned the best coach and GM this team ever had three years after winning a 2nd Cup and they gave the go-ahead for Blake to spend $18MM of their money on a 35+ year old that hadn't played NHL hockey for years. What they are tired of is five years of big contracts giving them no results. They don't trust these guys and, honestly, they shouldn't.
I don't say all of this because I dislike the vets. These guys are all made men in my book. As it relates to current results, however, I can be honest about their performance. The contracts don't matter: it is a sunk cost on a few of these guys. The main thing is optimizing the Doughty/Kopitar years since there are a lot more of those and they should be more than serviceable--hopefully much more than serviceable--by Luc's 2021 (more like 2022) time frame. This current draft is immensely important with the three picks in the top 32 or whatever. Having two first rounders next season would be pretty nice as well, if possible. Remember though that it won't just be 11/8 and current prospects: they will have tons of space to go after the kind of guys you want them to go after.