Boston Bruins All Bruins Free Agent/Trade Rumours and Proposals III

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/
Status
Not open for further replies.

BruinDust

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
25,129
23,761
If I remember correctly, you were one of the most vocal against trading Krug when I proposed it.

I'm not saying they should or I want him dealt.

But if they were to deal him, no way am I concerned with playing against him down the road against an in-conference team.

But I'd say that about the vast majority of players.
 

compan

Registered User
Sep 30, 2009
8,223
3,051
Nashville
As long as we're trading with Chiarelli, we have a fighting chance to give up very little and get a great return. Who is our Loui Eriksson, Joe Morrow, Reilly Smith and Matt Fraser that we can pawn off for a super star player in return?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JOKER 192

Oates2Neely

Registered User
Jan 19, 2010
19,757
14,395
Massachusetts
Rask only took the Bruins to within 2 games of winning a Cup in 2013. With his #2 dman out, and his #1 center playing with a punctured lung. All while posting postseason stats that topped the mythical Tim Thomas playoff run in 2011.

Trading Krug is risky business. Gryzlek isn’t replacing his offense. Who slots into the top-4 with Krug gone?

It would have to be a homerun type player coming back in return. Jonathan Huberdeau would fill a need.
 

BruinDust

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
25,129
23,761
Rask only took the Bruins to within 2 games of winning a Cup in 2013. With his #2 dman out, and his #1 center playing with a punctured lung. All while posting postseason stats that topped the mythical Tim Thomas playoff run in 2011.

Trading Krug is risky business. Gryzlek isn’t replacing his offense. Who slots into the top-4 with Krug gone?

It would have to be a homerun type player coming back in return. Jonathan Huberdeau would fill a need.

A need for what?

The Bruins have plenty of left-shot LWers who can produce offense.
 

bbfan419

Registered User
Jul 3, 2006
9,142
9,750
Moncton NB
6'3 215 pound 21 year old center drafted 6th overall...

I bet new jersey fans are going to love your take
I agree with GD4877 what does draft position and size have to do with it? He has not done anything yet in the NHL to suggest he is worth Krug, hence I offered the lighter Krug like version of Grizz. I am however not surprised you disagreed, most of the proposals I have seen you make heavily favour the other team, not a personal attack meant, just stating you seem to under value the Bruins own players and over value other teams players.
 

Bergyesque

Been there, done that.
Mar 11, 2014
1,113
660
Laval, QC, Canada
I think the way you mitigate the "might be/could be's" is by having a lot of similar prospects vying for the same spots. Odds are, they're going to hit on one of Donato/Bjork, on one of JFK/Frederic/Studnicka, on one of Zboril/Vaak, etc...

I also think the league is driven by youth now. A team with a big group of young upstarts trying to prove themselves is going to have more energy and drive on a nightly basis than a team full of established vets. We've seen how veteran-laden teams get complacent. There's a lot to be said for the speed and enthusiasm kids bring to a lineup.

Not that I disagree with you here, but as far as the debate of "youth vs veteran" is concerned, why do we absolutely have to put a team chock-full of veterans against one full of youths?
Can't we just have a mix? Some youth (under 25) pushing forward, some players at their peak (25-30) producing and some veteran (over 30) showing the way.
The way I see it, most recent Cup winners relied mosty on vet or peak players, but were not afraid to use some youths in key positions.
 

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,196
56,542
Dylan Larkin Or Sean Couturier is the kind of return I would love to see. Would certainly add for Couturier. He is one of my favorite Players. I do not think he is available
There not I’m sure but Milt Pappas got traded for Frank Robinson, John Kordic for Russ Courtnall, Rick Middleton for Ken Hodge, and Rick Robey got Dennis Johnson

Anything possible
 

Mainehockey33

Powerplay Specialist
Jul 15, 2011
10,225
7,764
Maine
Rask only took the Bruins to within 2 games of winning a Cup in 2013. With his #2 dman out, and his #1 center playing with a punctured lung. All while posting postseason stats that topped the mythical Tim Thomas playoff run in 2011.

Trading Krug is risky business. Gryzlek isn’t replacing his offense. Who slots into the top-4 with Krug gone?

It would have to be a homerun type player coming back in return. Jonathan Huberdeau would fill a need.
Why does Rask get all these excuses? That 2013 team was arguably better than the 2011 team. Boychuk, Seguin, Marchand were all more experienced. Krug and Hamilton both transformed the defense into a mobile unit. Rask had a great run that year no doubt, but it doesn’t touch Thomas’s Conn Smyth run.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Strafer

Glove Malfunction

Ference is my binky
Jan 1, 2009
15,875
8,922
Pleasantly warm, AZ
Why does Rask get all these excuses? That 2013 team was arguably better than the 2011 team. Boychuk, Seguin, Marchand were all more experienced. Krug and Hamilton both transformed the defense into a mobile unit. Rask had a great run that year no doubt, but it doesn’t touch Thomas’s Conn Smyth run.
I don't see any excuses for Rask in his post at all. And beg to differ, Rask's stats were indeed better that Thomas', so they in fact DO touch that run.
 

Mainehockey33

Powerplay Specialist
Jul 15, 2011
10,225
7,764
Maine
I don't see any excuses for Rask in his post at all. And beg to differ, Rask's stats were indeed better that Thomas', so they in fact DO touch that run.
I’m not saying Rask wasn’t great during that run. Joe Thornton had a great run stat wise in 2016, better then Crosby, but Crosby was the MVP.

Agree to disagree.
 

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,196
56,542
If I remember correctly, you were one of the most vocal against trading Krug when I proposed it.
I was probably the most vocal - one of my top favorite Bruins of all-time. Just a high end offensive player and criminally underrated defensively (he’s at least average :laugh:)

But you get back Larkin or Couturier or a Matt Barzal you have to do it

I’m in the HFL SIM and I’m picking 8th and have 2 more first rounders towards the end. So I’m reading all the draft pubs I can get my hands on about Defenseman, the stuff on line and have probably watched both drafts the one I get here and the Canadien presentation and INSANE how many sub 6 feet guys were drafted and how many times a comment on the draft show or written comparing a prospect to Krug.

Oh, and of course I have him on my SIM team one of first moves I made.
 

Gonzothe7thDman

Registered User
Jun 24, 2007
15,784
15,936
Central, Ma

Gonzothe7thDman

Registered User
Jun 24, 2007
15,784
15,936
Central, Ma
Nurse is the type of defenseman that would be worth trading Krug for.

Offer sheet him long term anywhere up to 6m and it costs a 1st and 3rd. Well worth it IMO. So either Chia takes a deal involving Krug, or we offsheet him. What Burke did to Chia with Kessel.

The big thing about people not liking OS' is you piss off another GM.

But in all honestly, how many years left does Chia have being a GM in this league?
 

Mick Riddleton

Boomer : This, gentlemen, is no time to think.
Apr 24, 2017
14,314
15,563

Spooner st

Registered User
Jan 14, 2007
12,944
8,100
The problem with is. There's only one Peter Chiarelli out there but who knows maybe he will part with Draisaitl next.:naughty:

What I mostly remember about Peter Chiarelli...
Binging a cup to Boston in 5 year.
After 39 years waiting for one.
But somehow people like to dump on the guy.
Don't know why they don't dump on all the other loser's that just screws teams and no cup.
There's lots of those to choose from.
 

BruinsFanSince94

The Perfect Fan ™
Sep 28, 2017
32,709
43,380
New England
Offer sheet him long term anywhere up to 6m and it costs a 1st and 3rd. Well worth it IMO. So either Chia takes a deal involving Krug, or we offsheet him. What Burke did to Chia with Kessel.

The big thing about people not liking OS' is you piss off another GM.

But in all honestly, how many years left does Chia have being a GM in this league?

This is actually a great point. You piss off Chiarelli....Big deal. If things keep going the way they're going, he is not long for a job. I'm going off memory right now, but was the last big RFA offer sheet the Weber one from Philadelphia? Nashville matched it, but Philly still did what is frowned upon. Did Nashville ever try and get Philadelphia back for it (something I see mentioned when someone says you can't OS an RFA, risk of it happening down the road).

Also, if you get your big-time RFA's locked up before they even reach July 1, there's never a situation where they could try and "get back at you". McAvoy would really be the only player. And honestly, if they want to offersheet a player like McAvoy, they're going to do it anyway (speaking in general terms).

If there is a potential for Nurse to be available because of money, I want Sweeney all over it. Nurse -- McAvoy top pairing? for 10+ years? Yes please.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad