I think this is a fair ruling of D1 college football. There is so much money there that it is just crazy that they don't have to pay those kids anything.
I think there would be a lot of issues if colleges had to start paying hockey players in the US. Yes, the big teams could certainly do it absolutely no problem. The other 88% of schools wouldn't be able to afford it. They do offer some nice venues to play at and the truth is 90% of the players aren't doing it to go pro, they are doing it for the scholarship along with the other pluses that come along with playing D1 hockey. You would just see a loss of many D1 hockey programs across the country. We definitly don't need that. We don't exactly have many thriving hockey leagues in this country so I wouldn't expect another league is going to come in and offer a better/more attractive league than the NCAA.
A scholarship, free housing, free cafeteria card isn't exactly nothing either. Most of these kids aren't good enough to play in any leagues that pay any more than that equals.
I have 2 friends that played football, even went to camp and preseason with NFL teams. They ended up getting their degrees on full rides and are now employed via their degrees making a solid living. I have had multiple friends play D1 hockey, 1 went on to play for Rangers AHL team and the other LA AHL team for a couple years. One ended in NCCA. 2 of those kids did well with the school part and one was always a rock head and didn't do shit for a degree. Just because some people aren't smart doesn't mean others aren't and can't get a degree while playing a sport.