Duchene is a high-skill, high-speed, high-offense player. As a prospect, he was much closer to Zadina than Tkachuk, so that comparison doesn't hold up.
We were losing to Toronto 15 years ago, and lost to Anaheim 11 years ago. The league has changed. Gary Roberts would not be the same player today, and our "soft, skilled" teams with Alfredsson, Hossa, Havlat, etc would thrive.
It's why players like Hischier, Makar, Petersson, Hughes, etc are being drafted so high. Speed and skill are at a premium. Not character.
Besides, there's no guarantee that Tkachuk doesn't get engaged to a girl who ends up feuding with Chabot's future wife, right? Character is such a useless buzzword. If you're North American and over 6'1, you have "character".
Gary Roberts would absolutely dominate this league now. Hehe wouldn't have to deal with the heavy clutchy players anymore.
BT is big, strong, relentless, is fast, good skater, good playmaker, High IQ, soft hands, good puck skills, fearless, strong leader. He wasn't ranked by everyone as a top 5 pick based on intangibles alone.
"not character" lol look what teams make the finals, what team's win the cup. They are choked full of character. Again, BT has speed, skill, AND character.
Haters gonna hate as usual, this is the Sens board after all, it's what we do.