I don't think he got a raw deal. The Chiefs were eating his defensive alive in those last two drives, getting 4-5 yards as soon as the ball was snapped and he made 0 adjustments. Shanahan had to even call a timeout in overtime to ask wtf he was doing.
That's who i compared him to a few weeks ago. Herbert is the most common comparison i have seen but my first reaction to Maye was a more polished version of Josh Allen in college. Josh Allen has a 1% arm strength that Maye doesn't have but they are both big qbs with strong arms that can make plays with their legs and are tough, willing to make throws knowing they are going to get hit.
Josh Allen also developed into basically the highest potential version of himself so as nice as a more polished version of Josh Allen sounds, there's still accuracy, footwork and decision making issues Maye needs to work on and how many guys truly max out their raw potential like Josh Allen did?