HF Habs: 2024 NHL Draft Thread

Who do you want at #5?

  • Tij Iginla

    Votes: 209 49.5%
  • Cole Eiserman

    Votes: 14 3.3%
  • Berkly Catton

    Votes: 92 21.8%
  • Konsta Helenius

    Votes: 13 3.1%
  • Beckett Sennecke

    Votes: 75 17.8%
  • Zayne Parekh

    Votes: 19 4.5%

  • Total voters
    422
Status
Not open for further replies.

VirginiaMtlExpat

Second most interesting man in the world.
Aug 20, 2003
5,191
2,758
Norfolk, VA
www.odu.edu
Hughes interview puts cold water on a left shot defenseman. Levshunov is gone for sure. Don't think they're Yakemchuk fans (skating on the back end is a prerequisite for Marty) so Parekh would be the only option that makes sense.
That was one of two Snake was emphasizing. If the comparable is Erik Karlsson, that is some player. We still need forwards though. Maybe one of our young first-rounder defensemen maps to a mid-round pick.
 

MarkovsKnee

Global Moderator
Nov 21, 2007
55,386
70,367
Toronto
Does Catton remind you of ?? Steve Y??

His game at this point is exclusively as a rush player, but a brilliant one. He attacks the middle of the ice relentlessly. He handles the puck extremely well for dekes and puck protection. Excellent playmaker, vision, quick strike goal hands. Really fast hands. He's competitive and doesn't get pushed around. He'll hack & whack when he needs too, and not softly, and he is not afraid to get involved in scrums with hardy facewashes. He'll help defend teammates.


There's no physical game. If he is forced to the boards, he's really weak and can get pushed off the puck quite easily. He doesn't use his body well in small places instead prefering to use his stick almost exclusively for poke checking. He doesn't do well in tight checking games, or with intense back pressure largely due to lack of strength.


Like most juniors, his defensive commitment waivers from shift to shift, as he's always looking for fast breaks. He'll also sometimes takes the longest route possible to come back to his own zone hoping for a quick transition strike the other way.

He desperately needs to gain strength. I don't see him as a center at next level. He's going to be a winger.

He's interesting in that while he has no physical/board game to speak of, he has an intense inside game. Everything is about attacking the middle of the ice. Most players who avoid physical contact are perimeter players. He isn't a perimeter player.

His comparable is Drouin -> Keller -> Marner.
 

VirginiaMtlExpat

Second most interesting man in the world.
Aug 20, 2003
5,191
2,758
Norfolk, VA
www.odu.edu
His game at this point is exclusively as a rush player, but a brilliant one. He attacks the middle of the ice relentlessly. He handles the puck extremely well for dekes and puck protection. Excellent playmaker, vision, quick strike goal hands. Really fast hands. He's competitive and doesn't get pushed around. He'll hack & whack when he needs too, and not softly, and he is not afraid to get involved in scrums with hardy facewashes. He'll help defend teammates.


There's no physical game. If he is forced to the boards, he's really weak and can get pushed off the puck quite easily. He doesn't use his body well in small places instead prefering to use his stick almost exclusively for poke checking. He doesn't do well in tight checking games, or with intense back pressure largely due to lack of strength.


Like most juniors, his defensive commitment waivers from shift to shift, as he's always looking for fast breaks. He'll also sometimes takes the longest route possible to come back to his own zone hoping for a quick transition strike the other way.

He desperately needs to gain strength. I don't see him as a center at next level. He's going to be a winger.

He's interesting in that while he has no physical/board game to speak of, he has an intense inside game. Everything is about attacking the middle of the ice. Most players who avoid physical contact are perimeter players. He isn't a perimeter player.

His comparable is Drouin -> Keller -> Marner.
The video makes him look very cerebral in causing opposing defensemen to miss. A bit like the recent take on Sherlock Holmes planning a few moves ahead and the anatomical implications in a street fight or boxing match. He seems to have an intuitive understanding of biomechanics, namely when a defenseman commits one way in a manner that opens up another lane to the net.

Everything else being equal, the team should select the most intelligent player possible.

Hughes interview puts cold water on a left shot defenseman. Levshunov is gone for sure. Don't think they're Yakemchuk fans (skating on the back end is a prerequisite for Marty) so Parekh would be the only option that makes sense.
Music to my ears. As you know I'm not a believer in strict BPA in the abstract, but a weighted sum of team need and BPA.
 

The Last Red

Registered User
Jan 2, 2022
1,544
1,742
Hughes might have also been spreading some "disinformation" - NHL GM's apparently watch Seravalli's podcast - to help in his dealings with other GM's at the draft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rozz

Leto

Registered User
Feb 16, 2023
994
2,131
Hughes might have also been spreading some "disinformation" - NHL GM's apparently watch Seravalli's podcast - to help in his dealings with other GM's at the draft.

He deliberately kept the ambiguity about selecting Michkov (going to the length of interviewing him), while many things were pointing at Michkov not being an option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MarkovsKnee

morhilane

Registered User
Feb 28, 2021
9,042
11,697
I have a hard time believing that Hughes is comfortable letting the whole world know they will avoid drafting LHD. Not to mention that a guy like Silayev plays on the right side.
Are you scared the Habs will pick Silayev?
Torpedo's coach is a buddy of Lapointe and the team captain is a Hab prospect. ;)
 

VirginiaMtlExpat

Second most interesting man in the world.
Aug 20, 2003
5,191
2,758
Norfolk, VA
www.odu.edu
Got a new avatar... just for the draft. :)
He was on the same flight as me once, leaving Montreal and flying to Detroit, as I recall. Right after the All-Star Game in Montreal (Feb 1993 I think). A bunch of top players (Modano and others I don't recall) and coaches were flying back to Detroit or transiting to places like Minneapolis. I was sitting next to Doug Jarvis' kids; Doug and his wife, one row forward, were so nice. Izerman was pretty focused on his reading, as I recall; sitting next to his future wife, I guess. Good flight for a hockey fan.
 

The Great Weal

Phil's Pizza
Jan 15, 2015
55,273
71,029
Are you scared the Habs will pick Silayev?
Torpedo's coach is a buddy of Lapointe and the team captain is a Hab prospect. ;)
Honestly I wouldn't be upset if we picked Silayev over Iginla. I feel like a player like Silayev is a lot harder to come by compared to Iginla.
 

crosbyshow

Registered User
Aug 25, 2017
1,874
2,575

As I mentionned so many times and David St Louis said it best here...:

Berkly Catton is a chess player.

He does not need size at all because he is smarter than everyone else on the ice.

Man..his zone entrances are off chart....a bit like Sakic, Ribeiro etc

He does not need to make hard pass all the time cause he sauce them in hole areas to his teammates.

The best in history for that was by far...number 99.
 

MarkovsKnee

Global Moderator
Nov 21, 2007
55,386
70,367
Toronto
The video makes him look very cerebral in causing opposing defensemen to miss. A bit like the recent take on Sherlock Holmes planning a few moves ahead and the anatomical implications in a street fight or boxing match. He seems to have an intuitive understanding of biomechanics, namely when a defenseman commits one way in a manner that opens up another lane to the net.

Everything else being equal, the team should select the most intelligent player possible.


Music to my ears. As you know I'm not a believer in strict BPA in the abstract, but a weighted sum of team need and BPA.

I mean I generally love St. Louis analysis, but his mention of his lack of physical play is almost laughable. It's like one sentence at the end of the video, which you almost can't hear. Lol

He definitely only goes over Catton's highlights. He's a rush player, and he's really good at it.
 

McGees

Registered User
Jun 15, 2016
13,762
27,336
As I mentionned so many times and David St Louis said it best here...:

Berkly Catton is a chess player.

He does not need size at all because he is smarter than everyone else on the ice.

Man..his zone entrances are off chart....a bit like Sakic, Ribeiro etc

He does not need to make hard pass all the time cause he sauce them in hole areas to his teammates.

The best in history for that was by far...number 99.
I think most agree he is very skilled...the main reason many prefer Iginla including myself, is thinking about the playoffs and our already not large team. Having said that, I'm ok with him being the pick, I like him, just hope we can get bigger up front with other picks/trades.
 

Goalfield13

In Bilbo We Trust
Aug 31, 2021
2,059
2,769
I think most agree he is very skilled...the main reason many prefer Iginla including myself, is thinking about the playoffs and our already not large team. Having said that, I'm ok with him being the pick, I like him, just hope we can get bigger up front with other picks/trades.
I really don't think the Habs brass is going to be interested in Catton.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McGees

Shutdown

Registered User
Sep 7, 2009
1,712
824
Montreal
if the choice is Catton vs. Iginla i think i would prefer Iginla.

but if the Winnipeg pick is an early 20s one and we can move up to the mid-teens and pick up a Greentree or Brandsegg-Nygard type player, i wouldn't hesitate to go Catton with the top pick. a reverse Slaf-Mesar scenario where we do size with the later pick.
 

BergevinBurner

Registered User
Sep 27, 2019
1,895
4,428
I really don't think the Habs brass is going to be interested in Catton.
It'll be interesting to see what happens if Lindstrom and Iginla are gone before our pick. I don't think they want a defenseman and I'm not sure how high they are on guys like Demidov/Catton/Eiserman.
 

The Last Red

Registered User
Jan 2, 2022
1,544
1,742
As I mentionned so many times and David St Louis said it best here...:

Berkly Catton is a chess player.

He does not need size at all because he is smarter than everyone else on the ice.

Man..his zone entrances are off chart....a bit like Sakic, Ribeiro etc

He does not need to make hard pass all the time cause he sauce them in hole areas to his teammates.

The best in history for that was by far...number 99.
I assume you didn’t mean to compare Catton to 99 but you kind of did. 😨
 

McGees

Registered User
Jun 15, 2016
13,762
27,336
It'll be interesting to see what happens if Lindstrom and Iginla are gone before our pick. I don't think they want a defenseman and I'm not sure how high they are on guys like Demidov/Catton/Eiserman.
I think this is the very likely scenario.
We are trending for 6-8 slot and I could easily see the top 4 forwards being gone - leaving the choice between Catton/Helenius/Eiserman/Defence
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad