It's players like Casas that make me wonder if talent evaluators / scouts are actually watching prospects play instead of just running with the stuff they've read or been told from another souce.
How could the guy be labeled as a potential better than average 1B? I mean, it's perfectly fine that Red Sox near guys are pumping the tires of their prospects, but how do neutral journalists fall for it? He's one of the worst 1B I have seen in a long time. Easily bottom of the league. He can work his way to being somehow fringe average, but you probably need the imagination of a Tolkien to picture him as a solid defender.
The range is the entire issue defensively. Verdugo did a good job improving his this off-season, Casas will need to dedicate in a similar way. He’s never gonna have great range with his size but some of these balls he needs to be getting to…Or at least knock them down
To answer your question about what national prospect evaluators saw- I think they like his soft hands and he has a really good arm (just doesn’t need to use it at his position). They definitely didn’t make note of the range being this poor though
If you saw the Pelosi draft thread you know how much I put into national rankings- I don’t think these guys have enough time in the day to make proper evaluations on all these players. There are so many dang minor league baseball players lol
It’s nice to see how your team looks from a national perspective but I certainly don’t take them as gospel. Typically the billion dollar operations are gonna have more insight than them.
The funny thing to me is that the soxprospects guys are usually more pessimistic than the national outlets are