The real problem with taking a flyer on a guy like Allison over Studnicka is...it's questionable how much or a marginal upgrade you're getting. But what you're clearly losing, is in sending the wrong message to guys in the room. I think everyone has kind of taken notice of the way Studnicka came in doing everything asked of him, working really hard in the offseason. Having a great camp. To just drop him because somebody else put their leftovers on waivers is...not really reinforcing the idea of "merit" and "work hard, do what you're asked and you'll be rewarded".
I think Studnicka also brings some more speed to the role. Which, with our roster's overall lack of that trait...is not a "nothing" consideration.
I wouldn't mind Allison here in a vacuum. But given our actual circumstances, it just feels like a "grass is greener" tinkering move...with very very marginal "upside" and some obvious, observable "downsides".