Could be. Watching Cale Fleury tonight, he looked pretty good. If something like that ends up being an option, fair enough.
But aside from the $50k to put in the claim, i'm not sure how much "risk" there really would've been in just claiming JBD and giving it a try while you wait to see what else shakes out on the waiver wire (or trade options). If something better comes along, you can always still just waive him and i'd imagine the Sens still take him back and assign him to their minor league affiliate as depth.
It's a fully buriable contract for JBD. So if that kind of penny pinching is the issue here, i'm not really sure how to contextualize that in the sense of what they're paying some other guys on the roster, and some guys not on the roster.