2023-24 Roster Thread 1: Entering the Starting Gate

Status
Not open for further replies.

BernieParent

In misery of redwings of suckage for a long time
Mar 13, 2009
25,187
45,982
Chasm of Sar (north of Montreal, Qc)
A non-tank could potentially work, but only if a) the Flyers GM and scouts identify the high-end talent that multiple other organizations didn't and b) the Flyers system develops this talent to the player's ceiling. What gives us any confidence that they can do either of these things well? They have failed much more than succeeded with volume drafting, trading assets to move up, and receiving additional draft picks to move back.
 

JojoTheWhale

"You should keep it." -- Striiker
May 22, 2008
35,883
110,909
A defenseman who plays 25 minutes a night is valuable, b/c he's unlikely to do so unless he's clearly better than the 3rd pair D-men who'd play more minutes. This is similar to why starting pitchers who go deep into games have value just by being durable, b/c it saves your bullpen.

Pitching changes happen at one pitch intervals. NHL TOI decisions generally are not made even on a game by game basis let alone in something like individual shifts. You get variation, sure, but you don't get the type of changes that move your average TOI all that much.

The only possible hockey equivalent here is Goalies and even then it's problematic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kudymen

Gregor Samsa

Registered User
Sep 5, 2020
4,270
4,862
A non-tank could potentially work, but only if a) the Flyers GM and scouts identify the high-end talent that multiple other organizations didn't and b) the Flyers system develops this talent to the player's ceiling. What gives us any confidence that they can do either of these things well? They have failed much more than succeeded with volume drafting, trading assets to move up, and receiving additional draft picks to move back.
Yeah, it’s tough to tell who’s more to blame, the Flyers’ scouting or their developmental team, maybe both. At this point I don’t trust them and just want blue chip prospects with pedigree. I’d take my chance there

As an aside, the Flyers might as well slap the GM tag on Torts. Maybe he’ll get pissed off enough next season and lace up the skates. It will at least give up the opportunity to see the vaunted GM/coach/player unicorn
 
Last edited:

Beef Invictus

Revolutionary Positivity
Dec 21, 2009
130,486
171,188
Armored Train
This is a myth. Outside of Vancouver, he lasted 7 years in TB, 5 in NY, 6 in CBJ.
Compare to say Gallant, who's been fired in his 3rd season by 3 teams.
Laviolette, 5 years CAR, 5 years Phl, 6 Nash, 3 Wash.

Torts seems to work best with rebuilding teams where there isn't a coterie of entrenched veterans who don't want to be pushed.

By "works best" you mean fails
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kelmitchell2

dats81

Registered User
Jan 22, 2011
5,733
1,654
Carinthia, AUT
Just watched Farabee on Nasty Knuckles. Apparently he doesn't view this as a rebuild and doesn't think that they are far off. Also seems to really appreciate the brutal honesty that Torts is treating them with.

I'm more and more getting the sense that the situation inside the locker room is very different from what is speculated on here.
 

Curufinwe

Registered User
Feb 28, 2013
56,994
45,413

Before the end of the 2022-23 season, Frost indicated that No. 48 has grown on him and he'll likely keep it. Frost wore No. 68 his first two couple of training camps -- not in honor of Jaromir Jagr, just because it was assigned to him. He was ambivalent about No. 48 at first (also assigned to him) but kind of likes that it's Danny Briere's old number. Before becoming special assistant to former general manager Chuck Fletcher and then interim GM, Briere did some on-ice work with Frost and was one of the player's staunchest supporters in the organization even when others (including head coach John Tortorella) were down on him and uncertain if he was an NHL-worthy player.
 

Striiker

Former Flyers Fan
Jun 2, 2013
90,286
156,967
Pennsylvania
Just watched Farabee on Nasty Knuckles. Apparently he doesn't view this as a rebuild and doesn't think that they are far off. Also seems to really appreciate the brutal honesty that Torts is treating them with.

I'm more and more getting the sense that the situation inside the locker room is very different from what is speculated on here.
Nah, that makes sense.

Most fans are stupid, most players are stupid, and stupid people love Torts.
 

DancingPanther

Foundational Titan
Jun 19, 2018
33,896
72,133
Just watched Farabee on Nasty Knuckles. Apparently he doesn't view this as a rebuild and doesn't think that they are far off. Also seems to really appreciate the brutal honesty that Torts is treating them with.

I'm more and more getting the sense that the situation inside the locker room is very different from what is speculated on here.
Why would Farabee, a current player on this team, say anything different?
 

Magua

Entirely Palatable Product
Apr 25, 2016
38,671
161,067
Huron of the Lakes
O'Connor wrote an article today talking about the 4 rumored candidates (Shero, Wilson, Mellanby, Poulin), and it felt like the "This is Fine" meme.

He was also weirdly complimentary of Shero in the article/comments, writing shit like this:


Screen Shot 2023-04-26 at 3.53.07 PM.png


He didn't. Sullivan wasn't even hired as an AHL coach until the year after Shero was canned. He didn't even hire Johnston. Charlie just totally mixed up Shero and Rutherford's tenure. Shero made 3 coaching hires in his managerial career. He re-signed Therrien, replaced him with Bylsma (6 years), and in Jersey hired Hynes (5 years). That's it. He also never mentioned the Fletcher connection, where Fletcher was AGM/advisor to Shero in Pittsburgh and Jersey. When you really dive into his career, you realize what a totally mediocre HockeyGuy™ he is. Inheriting generational talents, lottery ball luck, and an ability to unshackle 2 Cup contenders immediately upon his absence -- that is Ray Shero.
 

Columbus Hockey Dad

Registered User
Oct 30, 2018
1,045
1,502
O'Connor wrote an article today talking about the 4 rumored candidates (Shero, Wilson, Mellanby, Poulin), and it felt like the "This is Fine" meme.

He was also weirdly complimentary of Shero in the article/comments, writing shit like this:


View attachment 697136

He didn't. Sullivan wasn't even hired as an AHL coach until the year after Shero was canned. He didn't even hire Johnston. Charlie just totally mixed up Shero and Rutherford's tenure. Shero made 3 coaching hires in his managerial career. He re-signed Therrien, replaced him with Bylsma (6 years), and in Jersey hired Hynes (5 years). That's it. He also never mentioned the Fletcher connection, where Fletcher was AGM/advisor to Shero in Pittsburgh and Jersey. When you really dive into his career, you realize what a totally mediocre HockeyGuy™ he is. Inheriting generational talents, lottery ball luck, and an ability to unshackle 2 Cup contenders immediately upon his absence -- that is Ray Shero.
Can we hire him for just the lottery ball luck?
 

renberg

Registered User
Dec 31, 2003
7,246
7,516
Lewes Delaware
forums.hfboards.com
O'Connor wrote an article today talking about the 4 rumored candidates (Shero, Wilson, Mellanby, Poulin), and it felt like the "This is Fine" meme.

He was also weirdly complimentary of Shero in the article/comments, writing shit like this:


View attachment 697136

He didn't. Sullivan wasn't even hired as an AHL coach until the year after Shero was canned. He didn't even hire Johnston. Charlie just totally mixed up Shero and Rutherford's tenure. Shero made 3 coaching hires in his managerial career. He re-signed Therrien, replaced him with Bylsma (6 years), and in Jersey hired Hynes (5 years). That's it. He also never mentioned the Fletcher connection, where Fletcher was AGM/advisor to Shero in Pittsburgh and Jersey. When you really dive into his career, you realize what a totally mediocre HockeyGuy™ he is. Inheriting generational talents, lottery ball luck, and an ability to unshackle 2 Cup contenders immediately upon his absence -- that is Ray Shero.
Of the four guys mentioned in COC’s article, Shero is the guy with whom I would really have a problem. IDK about Mellanby. Poulin or Wilson would be fine.
Wilson has a nice body of work which can be evaluated as successful. The only thing with him is the situation with his health. I was in Milwaukee when he was with the Hawks. The general feeling about him was that he was a stand up guy; a hard worker who kept his nose clean which was not easy with that club at that time. He’d blend in well with the current people in the FO of the Flyers.
 
Last edited:

Magua

Entirely Palatable Product
Apr 25, 2016
38,671
161,067
Huron of the Lakes
Of the four guys mentioned in COC’s article, Shero is the guy with whom I would really have a problem. IDK about Mellanby. Poulin or Wilson would be fine.
Wilson has a nice body of work which can be evaluated as successful. The only thing with him is the situation with his health. I was in Milwaukee when he was with the Hawks. The general feeling about him was that he was a stand up guy; a hard worker who kept his nose clean which was not easy with that club at that time. He’d blend in well with the current people in the FO of the Flyers.

Poulin is almost assuredly the very worst -- and that's saying something. He was a disciple of the Burke/Nonis group that torpedoed the Leafs to a similar point in which the Flyers find themselves now. Screams smart rebuild. He hasn't worked in a front office in a decade, and he was a decade behind the times the last time he did. He's a terrible commentator. He was a bad college coach. There's not one single positive thing to which you could point. Worst of all, it would hurt Cap's heart to see another hero tarnished.

At least with Wilson you could say he built that Sharks team from the ground up for a decade and a half of real contending. There was a lot of sustainable good. His core aged out, it ran its course, he bled assets at the end, but none of that is necessarily unforgivable as a next-stop PoHO. That team fell out of contending naturally. Even his last acquisitions like Karlsson were bets on league best talent. Is he just at the Poile(ing) point where he's over the hill? Maybe. I'm rationalizing the least bad option -- with zero Flyers connections -- here.

The fact the Flyers want a PR-type more than a manager but with "hockey knowledge," who also won't step on God Emperor Tortorella's toes, which tells me they don't really know what they want. It's mixed messaging, per usual. And it sounds less tempting a job opening than some people make out. That's why we're being fed the names of has-beens and never-was's.
 

wasup

Registered User
Mar 21, 2018
2,496
2,376
Players are not going to trash their coach management or their teammates in public . People on here thinking they will or are are morons .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad