Who in the NHL doesn't want LTIR this way? That's the problem with some acting like they were angels by not using it. The players want the higher effective pay that comes from it, the team owners and their fans want to have the best team possible and the owners of most other teams realize when the best players are accommodated the league is better off.
The only contingent that doesn't want it are opposing fans looking for an easier path to wins. The powers that be don't give a damn about that.
There's a lot of complaints with the way LTIR is being used:
- Fans that want competitive balance don't want Stone/Kuch style cap circumvention. This is where the majority of hate should be directed, imo. it's a super easy fix with a tiny additional rule: teams must field a 20 active player lineup in the postseason that is cap compliant. players that put you over can be on the roster, etc., but your actual lineup has to be compliant.
- Murray's situation is different -- this is a team circumventing the penalties of a bad contract by exaggerating how injured a guy is. the team doesn't mind, the NHLPA doesn't mind, the player doesn't mind. what it does do is give the big market teams with surplus income an advantage, which does minorly affect competitive balance. I'm not nearly as pissed about this as I am the Stone/Kuch type crap, but it does still tilt the playing field a bit and I don't love that. I'm surprised the NHL lets this slide, given their previous enforcement of the hard cap and how this is effectively a soft-cap luxury tax ish type thing.
- then there's legit "this guy can't play" type LTIR: Landy, Savard, etc. the original intent was to give teams relief to try to stay competitive when they experienced unexpected long term injury like this. I don't have any issue with this, but it's being exploited in the above ways.
I'm a fan of the playoff cap compliance rule to eliminate the TB/Vegas nonsense and let the big market stuff like Murray slide, because healthy big markets is also good for the league overall. But Landy-type LTIR is a completely different animal, and shouldn't be grouped with the other 2 uses.