The AHL rule really sucks
I'm actually okay with it. There are rare instances of bringing over a prospect over to the AHL level under 20, like a McTavish. Yet with McTavish's situation, it's obvious his talent is NHL-ready. LW Tracey and RW Perreault were brought over to the AHL as under 20-year old prospects due to COVID exemptions and both first round picks struggled mightily. Both are still struggling to establish themselves in the AHL three seasons later. Fortunately for Tracey, the WHL opened up again during COVID season and he was returned to the Dub. Tracey needed that extra year as a 19-year old to add more mass and strength.
Tracey, AHL
Age 19, 2020-21 season: 12 games, 0g + 0a = 0pts, and -2 rating
Age 20, 2021-22 season: 55 games, 11g + 20a = 31pts, and -1 rating
Age 21, 2022-23 season: 47 games, 8g + 13a = 21 pts, and -17 rating
As for Luneau's situation, it's a better situation for Luneau to stay in juniors another season. He's still working on his skating and skating explosion missing from his surgery over a season ago. There's also the depth issue going into the AHL next season.
Potential prospect D in the AHL next season:
RD Helleson
RD Andersson (RFA)
LD/RD LaCombe
LD/RD Zellweger
LD/RD Hinds
LD Mintyukov
We probably want some veterans onboard too b/c the oldest player we would have if using only prospects is Andersson at age 23. Also, knowing the shit show the AHL club is today, it might be more beneficial to remain in the CHL.