Get Hayes at 50%, trade Girard for Dvorak. Re-sign Toews once it's possible.
Gabe Nate Mikko
Lehkonen Hayes Nuke
Newhook Dvorak eRod
Meyers helm LOC
Cogs
Toews Makar
Byram Manson
? EJ
Yeah maybe. Dvorak is a lot more appealing as the 3C versus 2C, but I think I'd still rather go somewhere else.
Personally I'd rather go the route of trading Girard for futures in the summer and then flipping those futures(Or other futures) for a 3C. Assuming G still carries reasonably decent value(I really think he does despite this boards prejudice against him at this point), I'd try and trade him to Montreal for Florida's 1st round pick. That is if Florida recovers and that pick ends up in the 20s rather then the teens anyway, if they dont recover and end up missing playoffs Montreal wont trade that pick I dont imagine.
So something like Wideman + Florida 2023 1st + Pittsburgh 2023 4th for Girard. Get a decent, cheap puck moving bottom pairing Dman out of the deal in Wideman as well.
Personally I also think a Hayes trade might work better with Newhook going the other way as well. As I really think if he isn't going to be a Center solution for us, he's more valuable as a trade chip then as a 3rd line winger that we likely have to pay $3M+ for this summer. A couple Flyers fans on the main board seem more interested in getting roster players/warm bodies back in a Hayes deal over draft picks anyways...
I suggested Newhook + Olausson for Hayes @50% essentially.
If they did those two deals... They could go into free agency next summer with a roster of:
Lehky(4.5) - Mack(12.6) - Mikko(9.25)
Landy(7.0) - Hayes(3.6)- Nuke(6.125)
???? - ???? - ????
LOC(1.05) - ???? - ????
Toews(4.1) - Makar(9.0)
Byram(RFA) - Manson(4.5)
???? - Wideman(0.8)
MacDonald(0.7) - MacDermid(1.0)
George(3.4)
Frank(2.0)
That would be roughly $69.625M. At an $83.5M cap they'd still have almost $14M left to work with and 7 roster spots to fill. Bridge Byram for 2-3 years in the neighborhood of what Dobson got last summer($4M) and then they'd have $10M for 5 bottom 6 forwards and a #5/6D. Sign a cheap veteran 4C for league minimum like an Eric Staal or Derek Stepan sort(Or a Darren Helm but dont overpay like we did this past summer), Ben Meyers would get a spot on a cheap RFA deal as well.
And on top of all that, we wouldn't have moved our 2023 1st round pick, and we'd have gained another 1st from the Girard trade so they could target really good value 3rd liners with those picks in trade like Tampa did when they traded for Coleman/Hagel recently... Or simply hang onto the picks and restock the prospect cupboards a bit in a very deep, very strong draft.