Finding a 2C for this 3-4 year cup window should be an absolute priority. The AVS can then reassess what their needs are later and if they need to do a mini-rebuild to create another window. However, finding a 2C could be the difference between no more cups and 2 more cups. The AVS are going to be top heavy for the foreseeable future, so they need to be able to rely on an ability to find cheap depth for the 3rd and 4th lines, and #5 and 6 D. Luckily, there are a fair amount of grinders, veteran Stanley cup ring chasers, or prospects like Meyers and Foudy that should reasonably fill 4, possibly 5 spots. 3rd and 4th liners are also much cheaper to acquire at the trade deadline. However, it is borderline negligent in roster construction to spend 11 million on Girard and Johnson without having the 2c position solved.
If the AVS really want to put themselves in a good position for the next 3 years, they should overpay for guys like Bennett or Danault. Effective 2Cs on bargain contracts. Newhook, Girard and a 2024 1st for Sam Bennett. Reacquire Jack Johnson and another depth defenceman for late round picks.
Heading into these year's playoffs we would have:
Landeskog-Mackinnon-Nichushkin
Lehkonen-Bennett-Rantanen
Foudy/Meyers-ERod-Compher
Cogliano-Helm-O'Connor
Toews-Makar
Byram-Manson
Depth defenceman/JJ-EJ
Then for next year, if Byram gets re-signed for 3.5 for two years, Meyers for 1.25, and assuming a 21 man roster, Avs would have 6.95 million in cap space next year to find a 3C and #5 and 6 D.
Landeskog(7)- MacKinnon(12.6)-Nichushkin(6.125)
Lehkonen(4.5)-Bennett(4.425)-Rantanen(9.25)
Meyers(1.25)- Free Agent - Foudy (850K)
Cogliano(1)-Helm(1)-O'Connor(1.05)
Toews(4.1)-Makar-(9)
Byram(3.5)-Manson(4.5)
Free Agent - Free Agent
MacDermid(987K)
Georgiev(3.4)
Francouz(2)
Given how little cap space there will be this summer, lots of people will be squeezed and may be willing to take short term deals to take advantage of the impending cap increases. Depending on the discounts people are willing to give, you could possibly get Jonathan Toews, Lars Eller, ERod as your center for around 3 million and then add Erik Johnson/Calvin De Haan for 900K, leaving 3 million for another D. Sign everyone to one or two year contracts.
The season after, there should be a 4 million cap increase which can cover Toews next contract. Avs are then basically set until summer 2025 when Rantanen, Georgiev, Byram, and Bennett's contracts expire along with all the depth guys.