redacted
Registered User
- Feb 24, 2012
- 66,961
- 53,747
You could say that any assumptions about any prospect's ceiling are a pure guess, but you still have to scout. To me, it is pretty clear that Newhook has some limitations in the NHL and those limitations are going to keep him from being McDavid. You can point to that goal on Thomson, and I can also say Thomson is a very bad at playing defense (he's a reacher and gets danced a lot). There was skill on that play, but ALL players who make the NHL are skilled. Even the scrubs (anybody remember Bordeleau?).There’s Is no telling what Newhooks ceiling is right now, just a pure guess. His goal against Ottawa (danced thomson) was a wow moment in terms of skill, he has the hands for sure. He went from barely playing his last season in college due to injury to being in the pros, I think he will take a step this year.
Tossing out all evaluations of a player because you don't 'know' is utter nonsense to me.
I think Byfield will end up fine, but Stutzle will be a star.. the Kings won't be the only team to regret the decision to pass on Stutzle either.For some reason I remember that the Kings board really wanted Byfield and not Stutzle pre-draft.
They got their guy.
We'll see what's happening but not looking like the greatest decision so far.