The thing that bothers me about moving G, is that if we can't re-sign Toews next summer we'd be kinda screwed. Last season of Toews, he's an unsigned pending UFA...do you trade him or let him walk for free. Also, with G gone, at that point we are down to 3 top-4 D men and one of them is Manson.
I'm almost wondering if Toews might not be the better option to move in order to get a higher quality 2C or a younger C with more term. Also pretty sure I'm about to get arrows to the knee for posting that even crossed my mind.
For the first bolded... Realistically either way you spin it we're probably only going to be able to afford 3 of our top 4 Dmen, going forward anyway.
Makar obviously isn't going anywhere so then you're likely looking at 2 of Toews/Makar/Byram/Manson, with the other two lost for Cap/Roster rebalancing purposes. IMO ideally in the next ~2 years you trade Manson. While he maybe still has value before that contract becomes a bad anchor.
What would really help ease the transition here for our Defense would be if Sean Behrens actually pans out as a Top 4D. I'm quite low on him and dont think he'll even play in the NHL, but others here are very high on him. I'd love to be wrong on his upside and for him to replace G/Toews/Byram(Whichever one we move) on the Left side in the next 2-3 years
As for the 2nd bolded, I dont know that we get either one of those things with Toews. Its safe to say we aren't going to move him right now... The earliest a deal happens is likely trade deadline at this point and IMO he's far more likely to be a summer of 2023 move because he's clearly the #2D on this team and keeping him gives us a far better shot at winning another cup this year. So you're talking about 1.5 years before he's a UFA or more likely 1 year. I just dont see a lot of teams lining up with a high end 2C, or a top end, A tier Center prospect, for Toews with just 1/1.5 years left.
That said, if somebody wanted to pay that kind of price, I'd definitely move him before Girard honestly.
Off the top of my head, Toews would be one hell of a fit in Florida(Lundell+), LA(Byfield), Ottawa, Vancouver(Pettersson)... But as I said, outside of
maybe Florida, I dont see any of those teams giving us that quality Center/Young A tier Center prospect for Toews so close to UFA.