He was very good last year, but IMO not as dominant as the PPG scoring would indicate. I mean, same for Ronning or Gettinger or Brodzinski or whoever. His stats seemed to give the imression that he was dominant night-in, night-out, which he wasn't. Last year was weird; it was a third of a regular season playing against just two teams and watered-down competition as lots of guys had signed up in Europe. Everything in the AHL last year was...off.
I don't know what the big argument is with Barron but if he does become a player in the mold of Brian Boyle, I don't know why that would be a bad thing. Boyle had been a premier bottom-six center and PKer for a decade-plus. If you get that out of Barron, that's a huge win. I've always thought he was more likely to stick at wing, but the Rangers seem committed to him playing center, so that's that, for now anyway. I think he's maybe a future 20-20 guy if it breaks right for him, but more "safely" a 10-15 goal, 25 point guy who plays a good 200-foot game.