Hockey Duckie
Registered User
Ive thought about a full rebuild for sure and we need to do it or we will be bottom feeders for the next decade. We can only do a hybrid rebuild if we had at least a handful of potential young talent and incoming top prospects learning from established veterans in a competitive environment. We just don’t have that legitimate young talent...
BM’s has been significantly underperforming in asset management the past 5 years and gave away too many big contracts that failed with career ending injuries, signed too many low risk low talent grinders. We also actually haven’t signed any quality free agents / prospects, and drafted any true stars even though many picks have made it to the NHL . None of our prospects appear to be locks as stars (hopefully Zegras) and we really haven’t done well in the 1st round since the Theodore selection. Add to it the fact that we have an unproven coach who might just be a temporary cheerleader for just another year before getting the axe.
Things could have been much different... imagine if we had Theo, Karlsson, signed a legitimate star player like Panarin... drafted higher risk/reward types like an Aho, or signed any college free agents even a Kerfoot?
Sadly, the full rebuild won’t happen... I actually hope we even tank worse next year to force the Samueli’s to make the GM change. We need new blood and I’m good with giving Madden a shot... hopefully he will be more open minded and willing to sign talent no matter where they come from.
What is this alternate history?
Bob retained the twins, Getz and Pears. Pears' wheels and game fell off due to injury. Bob went all in for Kesler, but he too fell to injury. Bob went all in again with Eaves, but he had some odd medical situation that none of us know what's wrong with him today. Eaves-Getz-Pears was a top line. Kelser is your 2nd line center who is also a shutdown defender. It's just bad luck with injuries. We got hit hard with injuries in 2018-19 down the middle of the ice. Grant was our 1C. We got hit hard with injuries on our blue line in 2019-20. We lost our top-4 (which included Gudz) later in the season.
Due to injuries, we're forced to rush a lot of youths. Lundestrom was rushed as an 18-year old center. Steel, Terry, Jones, and Comtois all need more seasoning, but with three forward positions open due to Perry, Kesler, and Eaves not being available, the Ducks were desperate. Just before the 2019-20 season started, Bob tried to trade for D Justin Faulk, this implicating he needed more veteran help on the blue line.
Bob's asset management has been more positive. Since 2016 to the present day draft, the Ducks have had two draft picks in the first round three times: 2016, 2019, and 2020. The rebuild on the fly has already started.
Theodore had time to develop and wasn't rushed to the NHL. And when we was up with the NHL club, he was on the bottom pairing being sheltered. Although, I find it hilarious that you shrunk the scope down for finding talent to the first round only. The 2014 draft was a good haul for the Ducks. We had only five selections in that draft and four of them made it to the NHL in F Ritchie, D Pettersson, D Montour, and F Kase (a seventh round selection). There's a superstar in the making in G Dostal, a third round pick from 2018. Then there's Zegras attempting to make the NHL after only a year in the NCAA, and he's a first round pick.
We just had a major overhaul between the beginning of last season till today.
New to the team and org since the beginning of last season:
NHL level
Early season
D Guds
Trade DeadlineF Heinen
F Milano
D Djoos
F Agozzino
F Backes
After the seasonF Milano
D Djoos
F Agozzino
F Backes
D Curran (Potentially, FA signing)
F Zegras (Potentially, rookie signing from NCAA)
F Zegras (Potentially, rookie signing from NCAA)
Prospect or draft pick
RHD Andersson (Kase trade)
27th overall pick in the 2020 NHL draft (Kase trade)
104th overall pick in the 2020 NHL draft (Grant trade)
27th overall pick in the 2020 NHL draft (Kase trade)
104th overall pick in the 2020 NHL draft (Grant trade)
Those trade deadline guys helped the Ducks go 5-3-1, including where our top-4 were out, D Djoos playing top pairing, and we won (the Avs game).
D Curran was the second highest scorer in the SHL last year. A defenseman finished 2nd overall in the SHL last year in points. That doesn't get any love from you?
I dunno if we require a full rebuild consider the haul to the roster I listed above. Plus, we do have young forward talent still developing in C Zegras, C Steel, F Terry, LW Comtois, LW Jones, C Lundestrom, and LW Tracey. Tack on D LaCombe, Thrun, and Andersson for blue line, then it appears the Ducks have revamped their defense pipeline in a hurry. Also, we have three selections in the top-36 draft picks in this coming NHL draft.
I maybe too optimistic about the Ducks next year because I do notice all these little things that Bob has done and what he's trying to address as a priority - defense, which includes forward play. We have an abundance of centers and defensemen going into next season, hopefully enough to withstand the bad luck of mass injuries to one positional grouping we've had for the past two seasons.