World Cup: 2016 World Cup — Team North America (Part II)

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
  • We're expecting server maintenance on March 3rd starting at midnight, there may be downtime during the work.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Galchenyuk has a much talent as Matthews

Not even close. If you made a poll based on who has more hockey talent it would be an absolute massacre in favour of Matthews. Arguing over who is better today is possible, but not who has more talent. If expect Matthews in his Draft +1 to put up similar, if not more points than Galchenyuk ever puts up in a single year.
 
Not even close. If you made a poll based on who has more hockey talent it would be an absolute massacre in favour of Matthews. Arguing over who is better today is possible, but not who has more talent. If expect Matthews in his Draft +1 to put up similar, if not more points than Galchenyuk ever puts up in a single year.

McLellan and Matthews fellow Team NA teammates seem to think very highly of him.

Hopefully if Team NA gets into a tight game we see Eichel-McDavid-Matthews on a line.
 
Damn, I guess if hf poll says it then its true

This statement from you may have been more convincing from you if you weren't the one who made the poll in the first place. Obviously you care about HF's opinion on whether Matthews deserves to be there over Galchenyuk or Jenner or you wouldn't have made the poll in the first place. Now it just looks like you're lashing out because you didn't like the results.
 
I think its

1. Canada
2. USA/Russia/Sweden
5. North America
6. Finland
7. Europe
8. Czech Republic

Yeah...that seems about right.

Sure Team NA has great talent and speed...Fastest team in the tourney, and as talented as any team not named Canada

BUT those kids may get pushed around a bit...Many are not nearly as strong on the puck as they will be in a few years
 
This tournament is becoming such a joke. Galchenyuk played on the world championship roster for team usa and single handedly stole the silver medal in the shootout, had a 30 goal breakout season, scored more goals than any player in the nhl after the all star game whos name is not ovechkin, yet he cant crack this roster? Not saying that trocheck isnt good but cmon. I wouldve taken even jenner or huberdeau. Galchenyuk should have been on the roster to begin with

I recall Canada winning the past 2 WC gold's...and USA getting bronze in 2015...and finishing 4th in 2016...

What's this silver of whence you speak?

Also how is it possible to steal silver in a SO? Silver medal winning team is LOSING side in GMG
 
Last edited:
Canada
USA
Russia
Czech

Sweden
Finland
North America
Europe

Would have probably been better groups, and possibly better for ratings. I think Canada - Russia and USA - Russia would be very popular.
 
take drouin off that line instead of scheifele what did drouin score in league last year 10 points.

Drouin's a great skater, slick puck handler/playmaker + he was lights out in the play-offs

He's gonna play a top six role on this team...setting up goals + sniping too...

Some guys take longer to mature than others...still Drouin's days as a fringe NHLer...short though they were...are OVER!

His early struggles and ( me first ) tantrums will be only a footnote in what, barring injury, should be a stellar career
 
No one thinks Matthews is better than Eichel right now except leafs fan



Galchenyuk has a much talent as Matthews



Damn, I guess if hf poll says it then its true

Alex Galchenyuk is by no means equally talented at playing hockey as Auston Matthews.

Matthews is compared to the likes of Eichel, Tavares, Kopitar, Sakic in terms of his impact in the NHL. Galchenyuk is nowhere close and is a defensive liability, which is why is not on the team.
 
Head Coach Todd McLellan with some high praise for Auston Matthews. Probably just more PR though.....

“There’s a lot of characteristics when I talk about Auston in the locker room that I used with an individual last year in Edmonton,” said McLellan, clearly referencing Connor McDavid. “They’re different players, but the ‘wow’ factor, the maturity, the size and strength and poise with the puck, the ability to pick up concepts really quick and for me the lack of intimidation.

“He’s not intimidated by any of the players that are out there. The Leafs will have a very good player for many, many years.”

Meanwhile he had this to say about Alex Galchenyuk....
 
This statement from you may have been more convincing from you if you weren't the one who made the poll in the first place. Obviously you care about HF's opinion on whether Matthews deserves to be there over Galchenyuk or Jenner or you wouldn't have made the poll in the first place. Now it just looks like you're lashing out because you didn't like the results.

Well first of all, the poll wasn't Galchenyuk vs Matthews, it was Galchenyuk + Jenner vs Drouin + Matthews. Drouin would win in a landslide against Jenner since he is the "sexier" pick.

Also, I create another thread the other day on who's the better Team Na player right now http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=2122475
Everyone who posted had Galchenyuk top 7 and Matthews bottom 4
So it means Galchenyuk is the better player right?

And second of all, I put very little worth on who hf thinks is the better player or the most deserving one. The only thing that interests me are their arguments.
If you look at what people wrote on the poll thread, you would see that were not a lot of argument on why Matthews should be over Galchenyuk.
 
Eichel, Gaudreau, Larkin and Gostisbehere could easily be in USA roster... This team robbed USA national team!
 
Eichel, Gaudreau, Larkin and Gostisbehere could easily be in USA roster... This team robbed USA national team!

And Canada could've added the best player in the game to their roster. The North American team screwed both teams over!
 
And Canada could've added the best player in the game to their roster. The North American team screwed both teams over!

Pump the breaks big guy. He'll get there but he isnt better than Sid and quite a few other players.
 
Well first of all, the poll wasn't Galchenyuk vs Matthews, it was Galchenyuk + Jenner vs Drouin + Matthews. Drouin would win in a landslide against Jenner since he is the "sexier" pick.

Also, I create another thread the other day on who's the better Team Na player right now http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=2122475
Everyone who posted had Galchenyuk top 7 and Matthews bottom 4
So it means Galchenyuk is the better player right?

And second of all, I put very little worth on who hf thinks is the better player or the most deserving one. The only thing that interests me are their arguments.
If you look at what people wrote on the poll thread, you would see that were not a lot of argument on why Matthews should be over Galchenyuk.


I put zero stock into what HF thinks about players. I do however put stock into what guys like Todd McClelland, Jon Cooper, Peter Debour, Dave Tippet, Jay Woodcroft, Peter Chiarelli and Stan Bowman think, and apparently they think Auston Matthews is better than Alex Galchenyuk.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I put zero stock into what HF thinks about players. I do however put stock into what guys like Todd McClelland, Jon Cooper, Peter Debour, Dave Tippet, Jay Woodcroft, Peter Chiarelli and Stan Bowman think, and apparently they think Auston Matthews is better than Alex Galchenyuk.

How do you know they think Matthews is better? Maybe what they are thinking is that Matthews will sell a lot more than Galchenyuk? Since thats pretty much the point of this tournament.

Anyway I'm done talking on this.
 
How do you know they think Matthews is better? Maybe what they are thinking is that Matthews will sell a lot more than Galchenyuk? Since thats pretty much the point of this tournament.

Anyway I'm done talking on this.

So the coaching staff cares about ticket sales in Toronto? You really think team NA with McDavid, Eichel, Ekblad the Leafs own Rielly and all the other talent they have would not sell out games in Toronto? Really? :help:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad