Chain
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2014
- 1,183
- 0
When planning for the future, remember that draft picks are four to five years away from real impact. A Doughty or Kopitar is a one in five thousand shot. Can't develop a team on those odds. Giving away NHL level players, even "garbage" players or "plugs" for draft picks can have a dramatic effect on a teams development curve. Not every pick pans out. Not every pick is an impact player. Trevor Lewis was a high level scorer pre-NHL. Ironically, he'd probably score more goals in a less defensively schemed system. IF, he decides to move to another team. Then, we can all complain about his lack of effort when playing for the KINGS.
Just be careful what you trade for.....
I don't think that's the right way to look at it. You're right that most draft picks wont turn into a Kopitar or a Doughty, and many don't pan out to be even close. But that's not a reason to not rely on drafting to field the majority of the team. It's precisely why you have to have so many draft picks, especially high ones, and be very careful when trading them. Quite a few people say "well, a lot of draft picks don't pan out so it doesn't hurt to trade the pick" but that's looking at it backwards imo. The way I see it, because a lot of draft picks don't pan out is precisely why you have to be careful trading picks and hold onto most of the 1st to 4th round ones because you don't know who will and who wont pan out. Still, a significant enough # do pan out that high round picks are very valuable. Obviously a good scouting and development staff can significantly increase the likelihood of it working out. But if you play 3 hands of poker or 5, all else being equal, you're more likely to win a game with 5 hands.
Look at our team now:
Kopitar - drafted 1st round 2005
Doughty - drafted 1st round 2008
Quick - drafted 3rd round 2005
Toffoli - drafted 2nd round 2010
Pearson - drafted 1st round 2012
Martinez - drafted 4th round 2007
King - drafted 4th round 2007
Brown - drafted 1st round 2003
Clifford - drafted 2nd round 2009
Lewis - drafted 1st round 2006
Andreoff - drafted 3rd round 2011
Shore - drafted 3rd round 2011
Nolan - drafted 7th round 2009
Carter - traded for
Gaborik - traded for
Muzzin - traded for
LeCavalier - traded for
McNabb - traded for
Lucic - traded for
Enroth - traded for
Versteeg - traded for
Schenn - traded for
Scuderi - traded for
McBain - traded for
Greene - traded for
Notable traded players
Jonathan Bernier - drafted 1st round 2006, played All-Star
Brayden Schenn - drafted 1st round 2009, scored 64 goals combined the last 3 seasons
Going back to 2003 we've had a total of eleven 1st round picks. 5 of them are currently playing on the team and 4 of those have played or do play at an All-Star level. 2 more players who were our 1st round picks that we traded, Bernier and Schenn, have both developed into very good NHL hockey players. So you're looking at the odds of a 1st round draft pick developing into a strong player who can make significant contributions to the team at around 1 in 2 in a good system. But it's no guarantee so you've gotta have enough picks to waste on the player you didn't know was going to be the lemon half the time. That's why giving up 1st-2nd round draft picks hurt - at best you're giving up any room for error and at worst giving up future all-star level players. Plus, if you're going to get any cheaper salary years out of the players it's most likely to be a good player who's up and coming rather than a good veteran you traded for or tried to sign in free agency.
Most good teams have a core that comes primarily from their own drafted players and most of those will be drafted in the top 3-4 rounds. In general, the best way to build a winning team that has any kind of staying power is to build primarily through drafted players and supplement with traded players.