Your teams all time team

[PenguinSuitedUp]

stopped reading w/Francis at wing

That was literally a line that was played when they were all Penguins.

But it was saying by own rules. Gonchar for sure, I forgot him. But 60 games of Zubov before I was born doesn't make it to the list. It’s about players I cared most.

I agree with this. I threw Zubov on my roster because there are no rules. But he’s less a Penguin than a Star.

 

[Soundwave]

Smyth Gretzky Kurri
Draisaitl McDavid Hyman
Tikkanen Messier Anderson
Kane Weight Guerin
Hemsky

Pronger Coffey
Lowe Huddy
Ekholm Bouchard
Gator

Fuhr
Ranford
Roloson

 

[Hamilton Bulldogs]

Kariya - Getzlaf - Selanne
Ryan - Zegras - Perry
McTavish - Kesler - Kunitz
Silf - Pahlsson - Cogliano
Moen

Neidermayer - Beauch
Pronger - Fowler
Lindholm - Manson
Visnovsky


Giguere
Gibson

 

[FunkySeeFunkyDo]

That was literally a line that was played when they were all Penguins.


I agree with this. I threw Zubov on my roster because there are no rules. But he’s less a Penguin than a Star.

Yeah but Francis was the center.

 

[David Bruce Banner]

Sedins - Bertuzzi
Naslund - Pettersson - Bure
Miller - Linden - Mogilny
Gelinas - Kesler - Burrows

HM: Smyl

Ohlund - Hughes
Tanev - Jovo
Lumme - Edler

HM: Reinhart

McLean
Luongo

HM: Demko

Coach: Quinn
GM: Quinn

 

[Joe Lamb]

He also left off Subban and Markov. And Roy in net. Crazy depth.

And Butch Bouchard ( senior) on D

 

[DitchMarner]

Smyth Gretzky Kurri
Draisaitl McDavid Hyman
Tikkanen Messier Anderson
Kane Weight Guerin
Hemsky

Pronger Coffey
Lowe Huddy
Ekholm Bouchard
Gator

Fuhr
Ranford
Roloson

I know Smyth is an Oilers icon, but should he really be on their all-time team?

You have so many other options at forward: Taylor Hall (Hart winner), Bernie Nicholls (150 points season), Damphousse, Ray Whitney, Arnott...

 

[milehigh11]

Avalanche.

MacKinnon / Sakic / Hejduk
Landeskog / Forsberg / Nichushkin
Tanguay / ROR / Lemieux
Deadmarsh / Stastny / Drury

Bench: kaminsky / Duchene

Toews / Makar
Bourque / Blake
Ozolinsh / Foote

Bench: E Johnson

Roy
 Varlamov

 

[Soundwave]

I know Smyth is an Oilers icon, but should he really be on their all-time team?

You have so many other options at forward: Taylor Hall (Hart winner), Bernie Nicholls (150 points season), Damphousse, Ray Whitney, Arnott...

I'm gonna be honest, Taylor Hall skipped my mind, but yeah. Smyth scored a ton of goals for the Oilers though too, so it's not just a purely sentimental add.

 

[njdevils1982]

Sedins - Bertuzzi
Naslund - Pettersson - Bure
Gelinas - Linden - Mogilny
Schmautz - Kesler - Burrows

HM: Smyl

Ohlund - Hughes
Tanev - Jovo
Lumme - Edler

HM: Reinhart

McLean
Luongo

HM: Demko

Coach: Quinn
GM: Quinn

glad there's a canucks fan that finally mentioned smyl

 

[KJoe88]

Basically any Wings player + Patrick Kane. He counts now, right?

 

[frisco]

Based on what they did in Pittsburgh only:

Forward:
Lemieux
Crosby
Jagr
Malkin
Francis
Kehoe
Guentzel
Stevens
Kunitz
Recchi
Pronovost
Straka

Defense:
Letang
Coffey
Stackhouse
Orpik
Murphy
Carlyle

Goal:
Barrasso
Fleury

My Best-Carey

 

[Mogo]

How the F do you counter that line? For the Habs I'd send in:

Bob Gainey - Guy Carbonneau - Claude Lemieux

Tough, smart and a bit dirty. A bit. Heck I'd sent them against any offensive line.

Scrub-Barkov-Scrub

 

[viceroy]

Yeah but Francis was the center.

I'm pretty sure Francis took the face-offs because Mario's back was shot but Lemieux outside of that took on the Centre duties.

IIRC of course.

 

[57special]

Blake - Beliveau - Lafleur
Shutt - M Richard - H Richard
Moore - Morenz - Geoffrion
Gainey - Carbonneau - Provost

Harvey - Chelios
Robinson - Savard
Lapointe - Weber

Dryden
Price

No Cournoyer, or Lemaire? Also, Weber played his best hockey elsewhere. You could argue Chelios did, also, but at least he was in his prime

Quite the checking line, though.

 

[Machinehead]

Hadfield-Ratelle-Gilbert
Panarin-Boucher-Cook
Kreider-Messier-Jagr
Graves-Gretzky-Bathgate

Leetch-Fox
Park-Greschner
Howell-Harvey

Lundqvist
Shesterkin

This lineup is less service and more so trying to make the best team. If you're leaning more towards service, @UnSandvich probably had the right team.

Also I just wanna see some of these combos. Leetch-Fox. Imagine seeing that.

Imagine being along the boards against Kreider-Messier-Jagr.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

No Cournoyer, or Lemaire? Also, Weber played his best hockey elsewhere. You could argue Chelios did, also, but at least he was in his prime

Quite the checking line, though.

If these players are all in their prime I am most definitely including Weber

 

[57special]

I'm combining Minnesota teams.

Kaprizov - Koivu - Gaborik
Boldy - Modano - Ciccarelli
Bellows - Smith - N. Broten
Z. Parise - JEE - J P Parise

Suter - Spurgeon
Brodin - Hartsburg
Giles - Burns

Gump
Maniago

 

[PositiveCashFlow]

Kurri - Gretz - Semenko
Drai - McD - Hyman
Simpson - Messier - Anderson
Smyth - Oates - Guerin
Weight, Hemsky, Peca

Pronger - Leetch
Coffey - Lowe
Keith - Souray
Visnovsky, Huddy, J. Smith

Fuhr
Richter
Ranford

Coach:
Sather
Muckler
Knoblauch
Quinn, Hitchcock

GM:
Sather
Jackson

 

[Classic Devil]

New Jersey Devils

Elias - Arnott - Sykora
Kovalchuk - Hughes - Bratt
Parise - Hischier - MacLean
Shanahan - Holik - Langenbrunner
Broten, Muller

Stevens - Rafalski
Niedermayer - Greene
Daneyko - Hamilton
Driver

Brodeur
Schneider

Coach: Pat Burns
Assistant Coach: Larry Robinson, Slava Fetisov

GM: Lamoriello

 

[olli]

Why’s miller on the 4th line and not even on the other team??

 

[Mike Liut]

Shanahan-Oates-Hull
Gilmour-Gretzky-Demitra
Babych-Federko-Sutter
Turgeon-Weight-Tkachuk
Extra: Unger, Berenson

Pronger-MacInnis
Stevens-Pietrangelo
Plager-Parayko
Extra: Bouwmeester

Glenn Hall
Jacques Plante
Ex: Binnington

Is there a better 4th line than that in this thread? Doubt it

 

[Finster8]

Richard Martin-Gil Perreault-Rene Robert

Miro Satan-Pat LaFontaine-AlexMolgilny

Tom Vanek-Dan Briere-Jay Pominville

Dave Andreychuk-Tage Thompson-Dan Gare

Phil Housley-John VanBoxmeer
RasmusDahlin-Doug Bodger
Alexei Zhitnik-Jerry Korab

Dom Hasek-TomBarrasso

Scotty Bowman

 

[yeaher]

Tanguay - Sakic - Hejduk
Kamensky - Forsberg - Lemieux
Landeskog - MacKinnon - Rantanen
Lehkonen - Drury - Deadmarsh

Toews - Makar
Bourque - Blake
Liles - Foote

Roy

I am sure there is better players (as I left off a lot) in certain spots and/or people will say why not X over X, but this was just my quick list off the top of my head

Kurri, Kariya, and Selanne spring to mind but they were anything but great in their one season a piece in Denver.

 

[Xirik]

New Jersey Devils

Elias - Arnott - Sykora
Kovalchuk - Hughes - Bratt
Parise - Hischier - MacLean
Shanahan - Holik - Langenbrunner
Broten, Muller

Stevens - Rafalski
Niedermayer - Greene
Daneyko - Hamilton
Driver

Brodeur
Schneider

Coach: Pat Burns
Assistant Coach: Larry Robinson, Slava Fetisov

GM: Lamoriello

I like how the top three lines have all different looks, You got the "I know where my linemates are at all times line, The Holy Moly Skill line, and the Hardworker line.

Each D-pairing has a stay at home guy and a more offensive minded guy.

Brodeur and Schneider are elite.

It might not be the best team listed in this thread but its definitely a team that is multifaceted