Your teams all time team

[Grifter3511]

I feel like tenure should be considered, like Gretzky is Edmonton, Lindros is Philly, Oates is Washington, Jagr is Pittsburgh, etc.

Jagr, Paul Coffey and Kevin Stevens played in Boston, but they were way past their prime and I’d never think of either one as a Bruin

Oates is a Bruin first, Cap second.

 

[Regal]

Oates is a Bruin first, Cap second.

Oates is a weird one because he also had those ridiculous years with Hull in St.Louis even though he didn’t stay long. He has a case to be on all three teams.

 

[Grifter3511]

Oates is a weird one because he also had those ridiculous years with Hull in St.Louis even though he didn’t stay long. He has a case to be on all three teams.

For sure. I actually think of him as a Bruin, then a Blue, then Cap actually. His Hull and Neely years were definitely his best. He didn't even get to the capitals until he was 34 years old. Crazy that he was then there for 6 years and STILL bounced around for a few more after that.

 

[tmg]

Rob Zamuner OP , there are better options.
How about Hasek and Anderson for goalie

Rob Zamuner’s thing is to be placed on elite teams he has no business being on. See 1998 Olympics Team Canada.

He should be on every team in this thread.

 

[SantosHalper]

Ted Lindsay - Sid Abel - Gordie Howe
Sergei Fedorov - Steve Yzerman - Brendan Shanahan
Pavel Datsyuk - Alex Delvecchio - Henrik Zetterberg
Bob Probert - Igor Larionov - Darren McCarty
Joe Kocur

Niklas Lidström - Vladimir Konstantinov
Red Kelly - Chris Chelios
Paul Coffey - Slava Fetisov
Larry Murphy

Dominik Hasek
Terry Sawchuk
Chris Osgood

GM: Jack Adams
Head coach: Scotty Bowman
-------------------------------
Players i've seen:
Brendan Shanahan - Steve Yzerman - Martin Lapointe
Sergei Fedorov - Igor Larionov - Slava Kozlov
Henrik Zetterberg - Pavel Datsyuk - Tomas Holmström
Bob Probert - Dylan Larkin - Darren McCarty
Joe Kocur, Kris Draper

Niklas Lidström - Larry Murphy
Slava Fetisov - Vladimir Konstantinov
Paul Coffey - Chris Chelios
Niklas Kronwall

Dominik Hasek
Chris Osgood

 

[Lyons71]

No rules, just primes: Ducks

Kariya-Fedorov-Selanne
Kurri-Oates-Perry
Penner-Getzlaf-Bertuzzi
Kunitz-McDonald-Sykora

Pronger Niedermeyer
Ozolish Vishnovski
Schneider Lindholm

Giguere
Gibson
Herbert

Gets a little thin on the 4th line.

 

[wintersej]

I feel like tenure should be considered, like Gretzky is Edmonton, Lindros is Philly, Oates is Washington, Jagr is Pittsburgh, etc.

Jagr, Paul Coffey and Kevin Stevens played in Boston, but they were way past their prime and I’d never think of either one as a Bruin

Oates is a weird one. I feel like Boston and STL have equal claim as Washington since his best years were in those places.

Edit: see others have made this point.

To your point. If the Bruins got to add Leetch and Coffey to Orr, Bourque, Chara, Park, Shore, Clapper, etc, would be silly. Should at least be limited to “the version of the player on that team”…but the OP is no rules!

 

[Jedub]

NHL Jets:

Tkachuk - Hawerchuk - Selanne
Connor - Scheifele - Wheeler
Laine - Zhamnov - MacLean
Ehlers - Steen - Doan

Morrissey - Byfuglien
Housley - Numminen
Babych - Trouba

Hellebuyck
Khabibulin
Essensa

HM:
Enstrom
Carlyle
Mullen
Little
Kane
Lukowich
Olausson

Pokey Reddick wins the award for best name.

 

[Skolman]

Oilers is pretty easy.

Messier - Gretzky - Kurri
Draisaitl - McDavid - Smyth
Simpson - Weight - Anderson
Tikkanen - RNH - Hemsky

Pronger - Coffey
Huddy - Lowe
Gator Smith - Klefbom

Fuhr
Ranford

Would love to make room for
F: Klima, Marchant, Horcoff, MacTavish, Hunter, Guerin
D: Niinimaa, Gregg, Nurse, Bouchard (will be on here soon), Fogolin, a little more than one season of Ekholm isn't enough.
G: Salo, Talbot, Moog

Klefbom? Wtf

 

[tmg]

To your point. If the Bruins got to add Leetch and Coffey to Orr, Bourque, Chara, Park, Shore, Clapper, etc, would be silly. Should at least be limited to “the version of the player on that team”…but the OP is no rules!

I mean OP said no rules - but voluntarily withheld Yashin and Heatley and Hasek. Even Ben Bishop, if evaluated by his peak non-Sens play, would distantly outrank Emery and Lalime.

 

[Minnesota Knudsens]

From memory, I'm sure I've missed someone, and good thing for no rules about tenure.

Sergei Makarov - Joe Niewendyk - Brett Hull
Johnny Gaudreau - Doug Gilmour - Jarome Iginla
Joe Mullen - Kent Nilsson - Jaromir Jagr
Hakan Loob - Dan Quinn - Lanny McDonald

Gary Suter - Al MacInnis
Phil Houseley - Dion Phaneuf
Mark Giordano - Robyn Regehr

Miikka Kiprusoff
Mike Vernon

Love this, but might prefer a shutdown D like Jamie Macoun in the mix.

 

[DitchMarner]

TOR hasn't had very many top 50 all-time level players (even briefly). The best player to have played for the franchise (all-time ranking-wise) has to be Apps or Conacher. Matthews is already up there among the best and greatest Leafs. At least Lindros and Thornton had short stints with the team.


Busher Jackson - Syl Apps - Charlie Conacher
Lindros - Thornton - Sundin (a lot of meat on that line - would be absolutely dominant down low)
Matthews - Gilmour - Ted Kennedy
Mahovlich - Keon - Sittler or Marner

Salming - Horton
King Clancy - Kaberle
Brian Leetch - Morgan Rielly or Bryan McCabe

Turk Broda
Johnny Bower


Not bad if you have knowledge of the older players.

 

[Ford Prefect]

Blake - Beliveau - Lafleur
Shutt - M Richard - H Richard
Moore - Morenz - Geoffrion
Gainey - Carbonneau - Provost

Harvey - Chelios
Robinson - Savard
Lapointe - Weber

Dryden
Price

This shows how far our beloved franchise has fallen: Exactly 2 players on your roster played this millennium. And TBH, I think Price is scratched for Roy.

And the Rocket playing center?

 

[Magic Mittens]

I'll try Dallas, and since there's no rules I'm putting Iggy in for fun.

Benn - Lindros - Iglina
Lehtinen - Modano - Hull
Robertson - Spezza - Jagr
C lemieux - Niewendyk - Pavelski

Seguin, Muller, Carbs, Turgeon, Broten, Gagner, Perry, Morrow, B Richards, Eriksson, Neal, Verbeek, Whitney, Zucc, Nuchiskin, Langenbrunner and more

So many forwards, you could change that fourth line, but I went with 3 playoff performers, and I would love to see that first line wreck havoc in the offensive zone.

Heiskanen - Numminen
Hatcher - Zubov
Lindell - Tanev

Hamhuis, Klingberg, Sweeney, K Hatcher, Nordstrom, Sydor, Souray, Mitchell, Mativchuk and more

Again, lots of D to pick from, I put Lindell and Tanev together as they were a solid shutdown pair, but you could switch Klingberg in there or whoever.

Belfour/Bishop

Bishop was great for us when he was healthy. Turco would be my third choice, and then there's Thomas, Moog, Oettinger, Smith and so on.

 

[Docgonzo]

No rules Kings all in prime, and I have some out of position because no rules. It’s just silly.

Robitallie-Gretzky-Kurri
Iginla-Dionne-Palffy
Nichols-Kopitar-Lecavailer
Kempe-Goring-Gaborik
Ex:Carter, Sandstrom

Robinson-Doughty
Visnovsky-Blake
Norstrom-Murphy

Quick
Sawchuck
Smith
Vachon

Realistically

Robitallie-Gretzky-Kurri
Taylor-Dionne-Palffy
Nichols-Kopitar-Carter
Kempe-Goring-Brown

Visnovsky-Doughty
Norstrom-Blake
Muzzin-Murphy

Quick
Vachon

 

[Mike Liut]

Edmonton, Detroit, Pittsburgh, St Louis, Montreal jump out to me as top 5

 

[Dread Clawz]

Carter Verhaeghe-Sasha Barkov-Pavel Bure
Matthew Tkachuk -Sam Bennett -Sam Reinhart
Ray Whitney-Olli Jokinen-Jaromir Jagr
Stephen Weiss-Anton Lundell-Nathan Horton
HM: Scott Mellanby, Eetu Luostarinen, Mason Marchment, Ray Sheppard, Radek Dvorak, Evan Rodrigues

Gustav Forsling-Robert Svehla
Brian Campbell-Aaron Ekblad
Jay Bouwmeester-Rhett Warrener
HM: Gord Murphy, Dan Boyle, Brandon Montour

Roberto Luongo
Sergei Bobrovsky
Tomas Vokoun

I omitted Jonathan Huberdeau, MacKenzie Weegar, Vincent Trocheck, and Ed Jovanovski as they were traded for players on the team.

 

[viceroy]

Kunitz-Crosby-Hornqvist
Jagr-Lemieux-Francis
Guentzel-Malkin-Hossa
Hagelin-Bonino-Kessel

How the F do you counter that line? For the Habs I'd send in:

Bob Gainey - Guy Carbonneau - Claude Lemieux

Tough, smart and a bit dirty. A bit. Heck I'd sent them against any offensive line.

 

[PredsV82]

Preds

Kariya Arnott Forsberg
Sullivan Legwand Dumont
Arvidsson Fisher Duchene
Erat Sissons Johansen
(We really do have a shit history of forwards, geez)




Weber-Josi
Suter-Timonen
Hamhuis-Ekholm



Rinne
Vokoun

 

[Hockey Know it all]

Kunitz-Crosby-Hornqvist
Jagr-Lemieux-Francis
Guentzel-Malkin-Hossa
Hagelin-Bonino-Kessel

Dumoulin-Letang
Martin-Daley
Määttä-Schultz

Murray
Fleury

Uhmmm

I’m not a pens fan by any means but leaving off Zubov and Gonchar as well as Staal is kinda sus

 

[Golden_Jet]

Preds

Kariya Arnott Forsberg
Sullivan Legwand Dumont
Arvidsson Fisher Duchene
Erat Sissons Johansen
(We really do have a shit history of forwards, geez)




Weber-Josi
Suter-Timonen
Hamhuis-Ekholm



Rinne
Vokoun

Maybe Erat?

 

[PredsV82]

Maybe Erat?

He's there.. 4th line

 

[FunkySeeFunkyDo]

A couple of these picks are kind of cheap, but since there are no rules, this one’s just for fun:

Francis Lemieux Jagr
Robitaille Crosby Iginla
Stevens Malkin Kessel
Tocchet Trottier Recchi

Coffey Murphy
Letang Gonchar
Karlsson Zubov

Fleury
Barrasso
Murray (huge part of 2 Cup wins)

stopped reading w/Francis at wing

 

[Miro4Norris]

Uhmmm

I’m not a pens fan by any means but leaving off Zubov and Gonchar as well as Staal is kinda sus

But it was saying by own rules. Gonchar for sure, I forgot him. But 60 games of Zubov before I was born doesn't make it to the list. Its about players I cared most.

 

[ValeriKamensky]

Barber - Clark - Kerr
Leclair - Lindros - Recchi
Propp - Giroux - MacLeish
Gagne - Richards - Leetch
Brind’Amour, Voracek

Howe - Desjardins
Dupont - Timonen
Joe Watson - Bladon
Van Impe - Samuelsson

Parent
Hextall
Boucher