Auston Marlander
I was in the pool!!
I think it makes more sense to take into consideration how the players actually were for the team. And to a lesser extent, tenure.
Leetch on the Buds, Adam Oates on the Oilers, or Mats Sundin on the Canucks is just kinda dumb IMO. It's much more fun to pick meaninful players who were fan favourites, played integral roles, and were a part of the culture and history of the club. That's why a guy like RNH probably deserves to be on the all-time Oilers squad for instance, even if there are "better" centres / LWers available.
I get that. But it doesn't look like others are. This seems to be, who are the best names to ever wear your team jersey.